The Pet Parenting Reset
The Pet Parenting Reset
Question Everything. ReWild What Matters.
Conversations that challenge conventional pet care and help you raise healthier, happier pets by getting back to nature.
Jan. 14, 2025

180. Comparing Pet Foods with Amy Renz

180. Comparing Pet Foods with Amy Renz
The Pet Parenting Reset
180. Comparing Pet Foods with Amy Renz

Amy Renz, the founder of Goodness Gracious Pet Foods, joins me this week to help decipher those often very confusing pet food labels so that we can break them down into usable information to be able to compare one to the next.

Plus, we talk a little bit about the new Restorative Recipes from Goodness Gracious that I'm so excited about!

Send us a text

🐶 🐱 Nutrition & Holistic Health Consults: https://jessicalfisher.com/product-category/holistic-pet-health-nutrition/

💜 Follow Jessica on Instagram https://www.instagram.com/thepetparentingreset/

📩 Get email notifications for new episodes:
https://jessicalfisher.kartra.com/page/tpprnotify




0:01 Welcome back pet parents. I have the wonderful Miss Amy Renz back with us today on the Pet Parenting Reset and I initially asked her to come back on because I want to talk about the new restorative diets that Goodness Gracious has available for you for your dogs right now. I think they are incredible and I want her to tell you all about them, but I also don't want to waste this opportunity because she is so brilliant and has so much knowledge to share with all of you, pet parents and me as well. That's one of the perks of doing what I do is I get to learn right alongside of you.

0:45 So I think let's just go ahead and jump in. Amy, thank you so much for being back with us today. So having me, Jess, this is wonderful. So enjoy, you know, every time I hear you speak, I, and I know I say this all the time, I'm just always blown away by the information that you share and how much research you put into that information that you share. And before we hit record, you were just talking about a couple of the talks that you've given recently. And one of the things, and I've actually, I didn't tell you this before we started recording, but I was actually creating like my own little worksheet recently on pet food math because there is like there's so much to consider and trying to simplify it for people.

1:41 And, you know, learning all the, all the things and trying not to be fooled with the marketing claims. One of the biggest things that I see from people is, you know, because carbohydrates are not listed on the guaranteed analysis. Fortunately, hopefully, I don't know, I think we're all kind of up in the air on what's going to happen with pet food regulation at the moment. But they're supposed to be changing the labels to where you have to add the carbohydrate percentage. But Even so, people, something so basic to, to, to you or me is like a dry food diet versus a high moisture diet.

2:26 And looking at the protein and fat percentages, people are like, oh, well, this dry diet has so much more protein in it. No, really it doesn't, right. So I'd love for you to kind of explain some of that to people to help them kind of get past all that marketing and maybe understand a little bit better about, you know, comparing labels of foods because it is apples to oranges a lot of times. It is. It is. Yeah. You know, I think almost everything that's on a pet food label is really designed to confuse consumers. And it's unfortunately, you know, we have some really good consumer advocates out there.

3:08 You know, Susan fixed in, you know, as the first person that comes to mind when we talk about truth and pet food labels and all of that. And she's done a remarkable job advocating for consumers. But, you know, it's, it's a huge battle. You know, AFCO, the American Association of Feed Control Officials that regulates pet food. It's the, the board, the people that sit on those, you know, committees and those of those panels with AFCO are trade association members of big and, and big pet food sits on those trade associations. So, you know, what becomes regulation and what becomes the narrative around pet food is really what big kibble wants us to hear. So there's a lot on a pet food label that we kind of have to cut through in order to get at the nutrients of what we're feeding our, our dogs and, and our cats. And you know, one of the one of the biggest things that I even see on real food packaging that can be confusing to consumers is something that, you know, you see a lot of times on raw food, free shy food, a little bit on gently cooked food. And it's that flame about 90% meat and bone or 90 to 95%, you know, meat and organs and whether or not that's actually useful information.

4:28 And so many people think it is. But here's something right to think about is that think about it being Taco Tuesday, right? You going into the grocery store aisle and you're going to go buy some ground beef and you walk down the meat aisle and you have a package of 80% lean ground beef and you've got a package of 92% lean ground beef, right? And there's a huge price difference between the two of them. And it's because the 92% lean ground beef has a lot more protein in it than fat. And so there's three times more protein in that 92% lean ground beef than there is fat. But the 80% lean ground beef is more fat than protein. So which one of those is in that package of pet food?

5:10 I you really can't tell. So that that information that's on that label, it's not really helpful. In fact, it can be confusing to most people, right? And so the best way to look at pet food is how human nutritionists look at human food. And that's where the calories come from. What's on that guaranteed analysis, though is essentially the weight of those macro nutrients in the package, those percentages. And we were just talking about this right before he went live. But you look at a human food label and it talks about the numbers on there are grams and their percentage of daily values. But the guaranteed analysis is just these random percentages like one of those actually mean. And so I like to think about my puppies are barking, but I like to think about it like as a mud pie, right? And, and if I were going to go make mud pies and I going to say, OK, I'm going to put a pound of dirt in here and I'm going to put a pound of worms and a pound of rocks and a pound of water.

6:07 What's my guaranteed analysis for that? And it's essentially 252525 percent, 25%, right? And so that's how we think about a guaranteed analysis. It's the weight of the components that that go in as a percentage of the whole carbohydrates as you mentioned are listed currently on pet food labels. They will be, but not for several years. And so we have to figure out first what that carbohydrate number is. And that's essentially by subtracting, adding up all of those things that we see on that guaranteed analysis plus ash, which sometimes is there and sometimes it's not. And if it's not there, you use 6% for dry food and 2% for a wet food, right?

6:50 Those with good rules and thumbs. And you add up all that stuff and you subtract it from 100 and that's going to give you a carbohydrate. And then essentially you've got to know from there that there's 4 calories in every gram of protein and every gram of carbohydrate and 9 calories in every gram of fat. And so the math of it. And I'll share with you a link to a, a worksheet CHEAT SHEET that we have so you can publish it for your listeners. But, but it's essentially, you know, you multiply your protein times 4, your carbohydrate times 4, and your fat times 9. And you Add all that up, right? And then you take your protein and divide it by your total, and that's going to give you a percentage of protein.

7:30 And you do the same for the fat and the same for the carbohydrate. And when you get those numbers, you know you've done it right because all those numbers add up to 100 because protein plus fat plus net carbohydrate equals 100% of calories, Fiber, ash, moisture, they might be on a pet food label, but there's no calories in those things. So the then you say, OK, I've got these numbers right. So what do I, how do I evaluate that? How do I know that that's healthy for my dog? And there's an, you know, it's not right for everybody, but it is a well respected, well recognized standard, the ancestral diet standard, right? And, and it basically says that it, our dog's wild ancestors got 49% of their calories from protein, 44% of it from fat and 7% from carb.

8:19 So protein to fat ratio would be about, you know, there's probably about 10% more protein calories than fat. So it'd be like 1.11 to one, right? And have a quick I to look right up there for you. So that's like that's the ancestral diet model, right? We do and we'll talk about this when we get into our restorative diets. We do more of an epigen, what we call an epigenetic diet model, which is a little higher on protein, little bit lower on fat, about the same on carbs to adjust certain needs that we see modern dogs have today that and issues that they and challenges that they have to deal with that their wild ancestors did not. So that that's essentially the the math of it all. If you're going to try to do, there's a couple of quick and dirty hacks you can do so because, you know, otherwise you're going to have to have a pet food label and your calculator and try to make sense of all of that as you're standing in the aisle with the freezer door open, you know, wondering which one do I buy?

9:22 So there's a couple of quick and dirty hacks, right? One of them is to just take it, try to get a quick sense on whether or not there's more protein than fat in that package. And the best way to do that, the fastest way to do that is to say, OK, my protein number on my guaranteed analysis, I'm going to multiply it by 4. And my fat number, I'm going to multiply that number by 9 and then compare those two numbers and whichever 1 is higher, that's the that's the macro nutrient that's greater. So that's one way to determine if there's more protein than fat in the package. There's another quick and dirty hack that you could do that says, OK, if I'm going to look at a, an ancestral diet model, right, 49% protein compared to 44% fat on a caloric basis, what would my guaranteed analysis ratio look like? And essentially it's 5:00 to 2:00. So you would want to look at a guaranteed analysis and say, OK, my, my protein and my fat are basically in a five to two ratio or higher, meaning there's more protein than fat. And you know, that will give you a decent place to start. And then when you, if you from there, if you say, OK, I want to compare this food to that food, then that's the best. Then that's when you're doing your full macronutrient calculation to compare the two.

10:38 Yeah, is that? Into your question, a little bit hard to do without a whiteboard and yeah. Right. No, I'll actually put the that in the show notes because I think people can kind of maybe copy and paste that into their notes app on their phone. And then when they're out, yeah, having having something like quick that they can just pull up and be like, OK, is this, you know, how close is this to the to the five two ratio that Amy was talking about? Right. Yeah. Because that's all my. All my graphics I prepared for the day well. You know it. It is sadly, as you were talking about, you know, these big pet food companies sit on the boards of these trade associations who sit in committees to create the rules and regulations that the states adopt for pet food to follow. And so it is very intentional.

11:45 I was going to use the word insidious which is probably accurate, but. Yeah. To, in my opinion, make things as complicated as possible for the average pet parent to not understand. So they flip around the bag back over to the front and look at all the pretty pictures of that beautiful cut of chicken and these gorgeous bright blue blueberries. And you know, all of the things that they I actually want you to be paying attention to, even though that doesn't necessarily equate to what's actually in that bag of food for your pet.

12:29 So being able to be that savvy consumer that says no, let me turn this bag around because that's where the information is that I actually need to know. And hopefully you know, and however many years when carbohydrates are listed, it will make it that much easier for pet parents to because I think, I think most people understand that they don't want a ton of carbohydrates in their food or their pets food. They just don't see it. It's not right there in front of their face. So they're blind to it or don't, you know, don't have the time, the bandwidth to do that kind of research. So if they're actually faced with oh, this bag of food has 45% carbohydrate on it.

13:22 Right, it will. Be easier for them to say, well that's not the bag of food I want. Right. Yeah. So currently we have to, we have to do the math to figure that out. And I think, you know, I'm not a numbers person. I'm not. My husband is. I will say he counts everything. He looks at everything is a number. We will walk into a restaurant and he will say there are 32 people in here and the average check is $15. And how is this place staying in? But you know what I mean? Like, he right, he just does that. He'll he'll count the ceiling tiles at the doctor's office like that's his thing.

14:02 But I'm not. So I would actually have to like pull out my calculator and do the math and say, OK, they're telling me that protein is at 32 percent, you know, whatever it is, they're telling me that protein is AT and, and figure it out and, and I'm sorry, tracked by 100. And also having to know that ASH is often not listed. Like that's a thing as well that people don't always know or understand. So when we are how do, how do you look at a dry food versus say a gently cooked food?

14:46 What are some of the things that you're looking at there, other than the obvious that the gently cooked food is high moisture so you would want that for your pet anyway when you're looking at the lay falls? Yeah. So I, I wouldn't, I wouldn't necessarily compare just a gently cooked to A to a dry food. I, I think, you know, you know, I did this really interesting research project for myself and, and presented the findings at the last feed reel Summit that I was at just recently. And I looked at almost 50 really, really high end brands.

15:29 And so, you know, I don't care how we compete to Purina Pro plan or whatever that stuff is, you know, I mean, whenever those things are, they're just, they're not competitors, right of our side. And they're not, they're and not even just competitors, they're they're ultra processed foods, right? So, but when we look at the bucket or of real foods, right? So the ones that are healthy for our companion animals, those would be the ones that you might find on Susan Thixon's list, right? Or Doctor Judy Morgan has a list of pet food. So, you know, these are companies that they've vetted and these are, these are really great brands. And if somebody's going to feed a a commercially prepared food and not do it yourself at home, these, that's the awesome place to start. Like, you know, find a brand on one of those two lists. So I looked at brands like those, right? So about 50 in all.

16:21 And I looked at every chicken, Turkey, beef and pork recipe that was complete and balanced for adult oral life stages and not a prescription diet, and I did the macronutrient calorie calculation on it. So there were 243 of those recipes. And. Yeah. And and of them only 26 met or exceeded the 49% K Cal standard for protein. And so, you know, not all that, not all dogs, you know, the ancestral diet is not the diet for all dogs, right? Dogs are individuals. But it's a really good place to start, right? When you're talking about, OK, what, you know, what is a healthy diet?

17:08 And that was really surprising to me, right? Because my assumption is that all these brands have at least, you know, an offering in that ancestral range, right, where it was, you know, a little more than 10% of us did. So I, I was really pleased when I saw how our diets fared on that comparison, right? All of our, all, all of our, all of our complete and balanced foods were above, you know, 49% on a protein basis, right, for protein basis. So I think that that's a really great place to, to a really great way to evaluate food and which one you want to feed, right, is to start looking at not just comparing gently cooked to an ultra processed diet, but it's to look at the whole macro nutrient picture of all of them in terms of dry food diets, right, replacing as little as 20% of a dry food diet with real Whole Foods, whether or not it's a raw diet or a gently cooked diet is going to have a positive impact on, on health, right?

18:18 We, we know that from several studies, the dog risk group out of Helsinki, right, did a number of studies. They looked at a mom's early puppies diet, pre and post Natal, early post Natal diet and then later post Natal diets and found that all of them when they were not processed diets or had more real Whole Foods in them, it had a lower instance on developing atopy in adulthood, right? So there's epigenetics that work for you right there, right? Mom's diet has an impact on what that, you know, that little body is going to have problems or health that they might have. So but water is super important. To get back to your question about dry food diets compared to fresh diets, you know, water is the biggest carrier for nutrients in our body.

19:05 And when dogs have a where they're constantly eating dry food, they are at risk for chronic low level dehydration. The food that you and I eat, it's 75% water. If they're eating a dry food diet, it's 10 to 12% water. And so those dry food diets can cause a whole bunch of problems #1 there's problems with digestion because we need a lot. Dogs need a lot of gastric juice to digest protein. Protein digestion is predominantly done in the stomach. And so when you don't have enough water or enough hydration in your body, you're not producing enough gastric juice. It lowers Peps in action.

19:45 And we don't get a good digestion of proteins. And that can cause allergies. It can cause, you know, a GERD. It can cause indigestion, all kinds of tooth decay, because there's dehydration happening there, which sets us up for metabolic disease. So getting as much real Whole Foods in the in the diet is really great just for hydration purposes. And then and then, you know, there's a whole bunch of more things that we can talk about in terms of lack of synthetics in a lot of real foods that now that we're going to see in or buy more bioavailability of nutrients, more phytonutrients that we're going to get. You know, our our gut, those microbios, those microbes in our gut, they digest fiber and bio active compounds, I3C, sulforaphane, campfrault, quercetin, ergotheanine found in plants and mushrooms. And then those bio active metabolites are then transported throughout our bodies to help us with many metabolic and immune mediated processes and detox processes and essentially to epigenetically eliminate cancer as a life threatening disease. So, you know, studies have shown that cruciferous vegetables like kale, cabbage, Brussels sprouts, broccoli sprouts contain chemical components that can prevent the dysregulation and overexpression of genes that are responsible for the uncontrolled cellular proliferation and viability of various types of cancer cells, and that those epigenetic benefits can be inherited by future generations.

21:17 We want to know why one or two dogs over 10 get cancer, right? A powerful reason is that of the 8.65 million tons of ingredients that go into commercial pet food, green leafy vegetables make up .05%. So you know, it's really important to get those things in the diet too. It's not just about protein and fat, right? It's it's about getting phytonutrients. When I look at our recipe by weight, right, what goes into it and we're, you know, we are very high protein. We're the highest protein products on the market, high protein, moderate fat, low carb. We're still using about 25 to 30% plant and mushroom components in our diet.

22:00 And that's because these things are loaded with fiber and water which have no calories. So by weight they make up a lot, but calorically they don't know. And I tend to like to break that down by, you know, that 25 to 30% into maybe 15 to 20% dark leafy and cruciferous greens, maybe 3 to 6% orange root vegetables because they can also be sources of starch. 2 to 4% fruits because they can also be sources of sugars and one to 2% seeds and nuts, because they can also be sources of fat set I I would put mushrooms in that orange root vegetable category too, because they can also be a little bit have a little bit starch component to them. Gotcha.

22:42 It there were a couple of things you said in there One, I am feeding my dog snacks 'cause she was whining at me. What's interesting and I didn't I'm just not smart enough to use the word epigenetics, but I. Was talking. I was talking to BC Henschen earlier this year because they, well, just the reality is, I think even though the media helped downplay it, we have had a huge aware, there's an awareness that came early, early on this year about problems still undetermined, but with some ultra processed pet foods making a lot of pets sick. Like even more so than kind of what we consider normal, that that kind of go under the radar.

23:41 And so I was talking to him about that. And one of the things we were kind of it was early on in, in, in this whole like awareness of the problem. And we were talking about the idea that, OK, you, you know, your, your mom, your grandma, whoever is telling you that, you know, you, you've always had dogs and you've always fed them, let's say Purina or whatever it is. You've always fed them this kibble diet and they've always been fine. And they've lived a long time and you know, whatever. So they're going to be fine now. But the reality as as somebody just like me observing all of this is seen is that from generation to generation to generation from eating this ultra processed food their entire life, generation after generation after generation.

24:38 Like these dogs just now that we have now maybe just aren't able to handle the these things, these high carbohydrate loads. All the toxins that are we know are in whether it's the herbicides and the pesticides and the AG ES all, all of the things there's not their bodies aren't as well equipped because it's been so many generations now that they have been nutritionally abused is comes to mind. And so I think that that's probably kind of in line with with what you're talking about. We can change that trajectory by starting to feed better foods to our dogs so that the next generation is a little bit better off and then the generation after that is a little bit better off than the one prior to that. Yeah, absolutely.

25:30 Just, you know, right on. I think one of the biggest challenges our dogs face today that their wild ancestors did not is being deconditioned, not having enough muscle to fat in our body. Fat is like a massive, it's the biggest metabolic organ that we have in our bodies, right. And fat or I'm sorry, muscle is muscle is medicine and it's connected to everything. It's connected to our brain health. And so, you know, when we are deconditioned, there are more pro inflammatory substances floating around in our bodies that fuel oxidative stress, insulin resistance, inflammation, you know, leaky gut, all these problems. And, and you know, so you know, our dogs are, they're deconditioned because of the diets that their parents, grandparents, great grandparents ate, right? Not necessarily because of what we're feeding them today or because we don't get them out for enough walks or all that kind of stuff.

26:30 They're just epigenetically set up to be deconditioned and, you know, epigenetic transgenerational inheritance, right, of the propensity to be fat and sick, right? Those are big long words, but they basically mean whatever our grandparents and great grandparents and that matters. And you know, the epigenetic transgenerational inheritance of the propensity to be fat and sick is a real thing, right? And it's fueled by those ultra processed diets, lack of exercise, stress and a rising level of toxins in our food, our water supply and our environment. And you know, again, when we talk about 60% of our dogs or cats being even more for our cats, cats are over 60%.

27:10 You know, it's, it's got it. It's that, right? Yeah. And so it has to be counteracted by the diets our dogs eat today. Just us. Well, and I think it's also why, you know, I one of the things I find myself doing so often with clients that I work one-on-one West is almost like a therapist. Like, please don't beat yourself up like you thought. You know, they come to me and they're like, I thought I was doing. I've even had because I mean, you know, I'm a mentor in Doctor Ruth's program. And so I have students that have gone through the program underneath of me and graduated and come back to me asking me to help them with their pets.

27:56 And I'm like, you know this stuff. Why are you coming to me? But they feel so defeated because they feel like they've done everything right and still something has happened to their pet. And I'm like, you have done everything right and it is the most you can do. And OK, maybe we can make a few tweaks here or there. But you know, you, you have to realize that we have no idea what happened to this dog or this cat before you adopted them. We have no idea what happened to their parents or their parents for them. And so we just have to kind of be a little gentler with ourselves. Even if we think we're doing all the right things, that nature is still like it's things are still going to happen.

28:43 And so that kind of does leave me into the fact that things do happen and when they do sometimes it's so funny. I was actually just recording with Doctor Chris lesson right before jumping on with you. So I was talking about this exact same thing where sometimes even though I very strongly feel like for so many animals, if they are eating an ultra processed diet, a lot of the times we we can transition them to a fresh food diet and we're going to see a lot of improvement just by doing that. But Even so, there are instances where we need more support. Sometimes we need nutritional adjustments and so I know you have worked for quite some time with some really amazing people. Doctor Ruth Roberts, Angela Ardolino, Rita Hogan to put these restorative diets.

29:45 It's OK, everybody listening as a pet verret. So, so I would love for you to tell me a little bit about the the new restorative diets that Greatness Gracious has available. Yeah, I'd love to, you know, I, I, I want to segue into that for just, you know, kind of wrapping up. One of the things that you're talking about as you're talking, what came to mind is my audience. I don't know if you can see her back there, but that's wolves. So I've read this really interesting study. You know, wolves live. Wolves can live 20 plus years and the and the larger they are the longer they live. Our dogs huge study done 13 million dogs right? A study done by Mars found that average lifespan or average age of time of death is 10.6 years.

30:34 So our dogs live 10.6 years and the and the larger they are the shorter their lifespan right? Why wolves live intact through natural selection right? Survival of the fittest. Our dogs exist through artificial selection. We breed a curated population of them because we want them and then we do sex or destroy most of the rest, right? So what's the result of this natural versus artificial selection for the last 13,000 to 130,000 years, right? I mean, that's about how long? A little bit up in the air. It's a 10, you know, order of magnitude difference. But we've been domesticating dogs for a long, long time.

31:16 So what's the result of that artificial selection for at least the last 13,000 years? You know, some studies have found that wolves have antioxidant generating superpowers. Our dogs do not. Our dogs actually instead accumulate lipid damage. So over time, excessive storage of fat in our tissues causes things like inflammation, oxidative stress, mitochondrial dysfunction. So mitochondria are those little power plants inside our cells, so they create energy, but like any factory, they pollute. And a lot of free radicals come from mitochondria. But it causes this in our brain, in our peripheral nervous system, which is in charge of voluntary and involuntary functions like mobility and urination and digestion. So when we start to see those problems happening in our dogs, you know this can be a reason we also fat storage in tissues like the liver, pancreas, heart, bone marrow can cause insulin resistance.

32:23 And those things set us up for a cascade of problems cluster of biochemical and physiological abnormalities that put us at risk for metabolic disease or put our dogs at risk for metabolic disease. So when we developed our restorative diets, it, you know, part of and part of that is in our mind, right? It's that we've got a difference between our dogs and their wild ancestors. And so this ancestral model we need, we may need to tweak a little bit, right? And you know, it's the model we applied to our classic diets too. You know, it's wasn't just something we kind of developed as we were looking at a restorative diets, but we wanted to do something in line in that model and, and also incorporate some really, really cool ingredients that put them together in a way that serves nutritional purpose, not just overall general health. So we, when we, if I can talk for just a little bit more about that model, you know, we're, we're utilizing higher protein levels because most of our dogs are spayed or neutered. And testosterone and estrogen are powerful promoters of muscle mass, strength and function.

33:35 Testosterone can increase protein synthesis, decreased protein or cortisol related protein breakdown. Estrogen plays a role in muscle formation, contractile properties, exercise, endurance, all of that. And muscle is super important. It's not just for mobility, but anytime our muscles do work, they release myo myokines, which are little protein signaling molecules and they're picked up by the brain and they help with learning and memory and healthy emotional behaviors and something really cool called BDNF. You know, BDNF, it stands for Brain Dr. Neurotrophic Factor and it supports the survival, growth and health of our brain cells. So, you know, muscle is really important not just for metabolic health and mobility, but our brain and our dogs brains too.

34:24 So we, we wanted to make sure that our protein levels were were elevated beyond the ancestral model. We wanted to look at fat right, because fat if we've got, you know, dogs that are have issues with accumulation of fat in their diet and we know that prolonged not only prolonged high carbohydrate diets cause insulin resistance, but so do prolonged high saturated fat diets, in particular the pulmonic and stearic acids that we find in muscle meats. So choosing high protein but lean muscle meats was really important for us in in these diets. And then also an abundance of beautiful mushrooms and dark leafy greens and cruciferous vegetables.

35:12 Because when we look at the whole picture of what our dogs eat, a high protein, moderate fat, low carb diet, plants and and fungi play a necessary role, right? They're the source of the antioxidants that protect the fats in our foods and the fats in our bodies from damage. Vitamin E and carotenoids do this really well. Carotenoids are found in dark leafy aggrociporous greens as well as orange root vegetables. We also they're also alkalizing to the body, so protein is acidifying. So they counteract the acidifying facts of a high protein diet. And some of the our ingredient choices like in our kidney diet can actually lower uremic toxins. So uremic toxins are the natural byproduct of protein and fat digestion and healthy bodies can process those things just fine. But when we have a body that's with kidney, struggling with kidney disease, that can become a problem. So when we so that's kind of the overall and plus we need those things to avoid synthetics because, you know, that's just religion for us, you know, but so, so we developed a diet called Rejuve for gut health and total body health. We developed a diet called Jing for Kidney health. That's the only one that's not complete and balanced because it's intentionally low in phosphorus, but it meets all the other requirements.

36:33 It's actually got 45% of the calories in that come from protein. So it's just under the ancestral model, but it's still by far the highest protein kidney diet that you'll find out there and higher than it's got more protein than most raw foods and most most foods on the market anyway. So it's a which is great for early to mid stage kidney disease. And in some cases, I was just listening to Barbara Royal talk at the feed rail summit about kidney disease. And even in late stage kidney disease, she never restricts protein. So, so just tuck that in the back of your mind there. And then we use, we have jive for brain health and reveal for metabolic health. So we're utilizing in most of these recipes medicinal mushrooms, so like shiitake and oyster mushroom and in Raju, my Taki mushroom in reveal lion's mane and reishi mushroom in our brain health one because each of these mushrooms is known to excel in those particular areas, right? Reishi and oyster mushroom are, I'm sorry, Reishi and lion's mane mushroom, for example, can work or they're adaptogenic and they can protect and regenerate nerve fibers. They can improve sleep and cognition, reduce stress and anxiety and stress and anxiety is bad for everything in the body, right?

37:59 It's bad for muscle health, bad for brain health, bad for our gut. We're utilizing Rita Hogan was amazing. She helped us with our herbal additions. Angela helped us with our mushroom additions, Angela Ardolino. So we're very honored to work with the both of them. So in our gut recipe, we're utilizing calendula and plantain leaf. Calendula, we often think of it for skin wounds, but it's healing to the gut in the same way it is to the skin. It can also stimulate digestive secretions and lymphatics. Plantain leaf supports the production of a substance called glycocalyx, which is a sticky substance that helps commensal bacteria adhere to the gut wall.

38:41 It also boosts the replication of healthy gut lining cells and that protective mucus layer in the gut. We're utilizing bilberries and plums in that one because they're like supercharged blueberries, but the fiber and plums is really great for a healthy gut. Spinach is in that one too, because spinach is a crazy good anti cancer and longevity booster. It's gut food, brain food, metabolic food. It's high in those carotenoids, which protect the oxidation of fats in our bodies, and in that one where our main protein is pork, because it's energetically neutral and lean, we're using pork liver too. It's also loaded with B vitamins, zinc, and selenium that together support joints, immune function, thyroid function, and tons of enzymatic functions in the body. It's also high in B3 and some really, really cool kind of brainy scientific studies have shown that B3 supports the mitochondria, the communication inside our cells between our mitochondria and our and our mitochondrial DNA and our nucleic DNA.

39:52 And that communication when it's like really active is a hallmark of like really young bodies. And so science scientists have been able to reverse aging in mice by boosting this intracellular communication. And vitamin B3 plays a role in that, which is really fascinating. So. Wow. Yeah, Yep, we're used a lot. We're just using nettles in a couple of our recipes. Nettles are great for adrenal function, kidneys and nerves. They help balance cortisol, histamines in our bodies, as well as serotonin.

40:36 The So those are really, really great our kidney diet, we're using marshmallow root and BlackBerry leaf because they can and ginger root because they can strengthen and tone kidney function right and prevent UTI's and do a whole bunch of really good stuff for for kidney health. So they're really, really fascinating recipes where I love our sprouts. I can't even stop talking about them. So we were using we, so we partnered with a local woman owned farm that makes gross organic broccoli sprouts and mung bean sprouts. And so we're using those in in some of our recipes, which I'm really, really excited about. Oh, I love that I can.

41:21 Go on and on. But you know, you probably have to cut me off, so no. No, it's OK. I love, I love that. And I love that you're passionate about them because they, they look absolutely amazing. And you mentioned the kidney diet a couple of times and you kind of made a point to talk a little bit about Doctor Barbara Royal and not doing low protein for kidney. And that is a big, I think that's pretty controversial. I happen to be kind of in agreeance with that. And it, it's been one of those things. I actually was just instructing one of my students the other day because for her homework, she was like, well, I'm going to make the kidney diet for my dog.

42:09 And I'm like, please do not like there is, yeah, I do not want that low of protein in your dog. And I think there's so much to weigh there, which I think there is. That's why there's so much controversy because on one hand we do want lower phosphorus because, you know, the kidney just can't function, is not functioning the way it's supposed to be. It can't handle the same amount of, of, you know, filtration of toxins of, of phosphorus of even, you know, breaking down proteins and all of that. But on the other hand, our dogs and cats are carnivores.

42:50 And they, I know there's, there's also controversy on that omnivorous carnivores for dogs, whatever they're carnivores, they're all carnivores. They need meat. They need the essential amino acids from meat to thrive, to survive. And when we decrease the protein in their diet, their body has to get those amino acids from somewhere. So they're, they're, they're literally going to cannibalize their own muscle in their body. So it, it really is this like balance of, you know, if you have a dog or a cat that is just diagnosed with kidney disease and maybe it's a stage one, maybe even a stage 2 that you know, your vet is telling you. I.

43:35 Personally cannot see decreasing the protein for this animal. Like yes, we need to work on kidney health, but decreasing protein isn't the way to Do you want to talk a little bit about what you learned with creating? This stuff more than happy to so IIA 100% agree with you. You know, the, the, I think, I think perhaps veterinarians when they give guidance, right about kidney health, it gets oversimplified. And so because phosphorus is found very in high levels in most meats and organs, right, that low phosphorus diet gets translated into or interpreted as low protein.

44:27 And but low protein diets are bad, like they're bad for kidney health for so many reasons in because of the ones you named. Also, because uremic toxins can are already causing a breakdown of muscle in, in the body and generally kidney disease, you know, it's not like kidney disease happens in a vacuum in the body. Kidney disease happens because there's a whole bunch of other things playing a role in there. Thyroid generally gets thrown in there. Pancreatic, pancreatic issues, diabetes gets, you know, thrown into all of that complex disease process generally.

45:08 And, and those things are going to cause accumulation of fat and muscle tissue, which breaks down fat and makes us, you know, weak and stiff and sore. And that leads to more deconditioning, right, That we started talking about at the outset, right? The, the problem that our dogs or the way our dogs differ from the wild ancestors is that they're more, you know, more prone to deconditioning. So, but protein is really, really important for, for kidney dogs because the nature of that disease is to cause muscle wasting. And the fastest way to get to get sicker is to not move, right. And so you need muscle to move, You need muscle to feel better.

45:51 Exercise is going to release endorphins in your body naturally making you feel better. It's going to increase the health and size of the hippocampus, making your brain better, you know, and all of that. And your brain and your brain health is tied into your kidney health. So when we talk about protein and in particular animal protein, so animal proteins are high in branched chant amino acids like isoleucine and leucine and these things, you know, generally speaking, in fed states, muscle protein synthesis exceeds muscle protein breakdown, right? And they'll reverse is true in fasted states, but but animal protein causes it's least studies show that it it is linked or causes a higher and more sustained synthesis of protein in our body, which we need.

46:40 It was just how muscle is made right. And so making sure that we get enough meat in our diet helps with that, that protein. So there's a whole cascade of problems, right, when we have kidney health and, and our kidney issues. So, you know, generally speaking, it's, you know, we have the microscopic little filters in our kidneys, right? And, and they, their job is, is to, you know, obviously to filter. And so when we have problems or generally we'll have circulatory micro circulation problems that cause not enough nutrients reaching those kidneys and reaching those microscopic filters and that that's what causes that problem.

47:21 So when we have later stages in the disease, we're not able to control acid based balance in our body really well. We can't control or regulate electrolytes and water very well. So we're having, we might have had hypertension, but now we've got a worsening of hypertension and that creates a cyclical process of further damaging those blood vessels. We have eventually become anemic in later stages of the disease because erythropoietin is the hormone that's released by the kidneys that tells our bone marrow to make red blood cells. And our kidneys are involved in glucose because it manufacturers glucose from amino acids at at a rate that's pretty much rivals the liver.

48:08 And so that organ is really important for, for that function. So, you know, I mean, I'm, I think I'm rambling on, but, but, but maintaining, you know, but protein is really important. Making sure we're getting enough dark, you know, dark leafy cruciferous greens in our diet is really important because they're alkalizing And our kidneys, you know, if they're not functioning properly, our body's going to become acidic. So, you know, we want to make sure we have that fresh food diets are super important, right? Because kidneys need water to be able to do their job really, really well. And dry food diets are just the, I mean, they've got, they've got to be as equally bad as low protein diets for kidney disease. I agree.

48:56 I mean, I tell people all the time like hydration as a hill I'm going to die on over and above anything else, hydration is, is the hill I will die on. But so you have been able with the restorative diet for the one that's called Jing for kidney, you have been able to do the low phosphorus well as you said, keeping the protein exactly. Right. So what we're using in in that one is so our protein sources are egg whites. So egg whites are really, really high in protein, but but really low in phosphorus. So we're getting a lot of protein from that.

49:36 We're also using the whole egg because we need choline levels and we, it's really important for us to get natural choline because synthetic choline is very damaging to the kidneys. And you know, believe it or not, prescription or therapeutic diets or kidney like kidney friendly diets have synthetic choline in them. So I would encourage people to try to find another alternative than that diet. So, so we, we're utilizing whole eggs to get the choline in them, but not as not not enough so that you know, our phosphorus levels are really high. And then we're also using pork kidney because kidney, pork kidney is energetically neutral.

50:17 It's nutrient dense and rich protein source inspired at low phosphorus and inspired by the principle of like heels like. So those are those are predominant protein sources that that we're using in, in that recipe. I love that. And I know you do have another call to get to soon. So, yeah, I think this was so incredibly informative and this is, you know, going to help people both with understanding pet food labels a little bit more, which, you know, the reality is that not everybody out there is able to feed 100% fresh food diets all the time.

51:01 So providing information to people to be able to make the best decisions possible with the information they have available to them is, is so important to me. I tell people all the time, like what, you know, I get asked a question, what if I, you know, I'm just in that financial situation where I, I can only afford kibble and I'm like, OK, let's do like the some of the cheapest kibble and put as much of that budget into fresh foods on top of it. Like let's, you know, because the reality is ultra processed food is ultra processed food. And we can argue semantics about the quality of ingredients and different ultra processed foods, but it's still ultra processed, right?

51:54 I think I think that that's good advice, right? I mean as much as much of that ultra processed food as you can replace with Whole Foods. You know, if it if it means that, OK, instead of buying a high end kibble, I'm going to buy a low end kibble, right. I mean, obviously there's there are really bad ones, but you know, Yeah, yeah. For sure. Like I, I, I gotcha right. Then take that money and, and apply it to a a whole food diet as and mix it in as much as I can, you know, Bravo. You know, I mean, I think that that's, that's a really great approach. Yeah.

52:35 And, you know, they're, they're designed to be, you know, all of them are designed to be either whole, the whole food or a mix in or a Topper. I mean, that was really important for us too, is, you know, we've got herbs and medicinal mushrooms in there at therapeutic levels, But they're they are things that you can have every day. And, you know, for the long term, because kidney disease really is not necessarily it's not something you cure. It's just something that you so slow the progression of. Oh yes for sure. I think it's like 1 of the only, the only organ that doesn't really regenerate, right. Like, yeah, yeah. So I, I, I love everything you're doing. And goodness gracious, I'm super excited about the new restorative diets for dogs.

53:22 And you do have cat recipes in your regular. Yeah, we do. We do. Which I love, especially if people can get their cats transitioned earlier on in life. I mean, it's still possible later on in life, but much, much harder. So I never want to leave the kiddies out of it because they are super, super important to me. And I think possibly often like they, they get less veterinary care than dogs do. I think more often than not they're fed more poorly than dogs because they are so finicky. They are implant, implant, imprint theater. It's just harder, harder to transition them. So the earlier the better.

54:09 But I love that you also have some some cat recipes for people and where can people find you? Where can they buy the food? How can they follow you on social? Because Oh my gosh, the information you have is so incredible. Oh. Thank you. Yeah, yeah. So, so we're on Facebook, we're on Instagram, Goodness gracious Pat and our website, Goodness gracious Co. You can find us there. You can order online and then or depending upon where you live, you could find it in, in your local store. So if anybody wants to e-mail our customer service, if they don't see it in their local store, e-mail us and we'll try to point you in the right direction. We're, we're not nationwide yet.

54:55 We're, we're working on it, right? But you know, 11 place at a time, one step at a time. So yeah, absolutely. Well, I certainly appreciate you and everything that you do to make pets lives better. I can't wait to see you speak in person again one day. And I don't guys. I'm just. Going to say I'm going to be at the Nautical Dog event in July. So that'll be that'll be fine. And then there's a couple of other things that are potentially coming up, but we'll talk about those. When they're official, I, I do love going to the knuckle dog event. I get to kind of do a duel. That's where I'm from Hampton Roads. So I go like, I go to the event and then I go like see my family.

55:42 So it's like a kill. Well, I go, I, I generally I'll go to North Carolina, see my grandparents, then I'll go to the event and then I'll go to Suffolk and see my family. And so I get to, you know, kill a whole bunch of birds with 1 stuff. But thank you again, Amy. I so appreciate you. And for everybody listening, please check the show notes for hopefully some simplified math that you can just copy and paste into your notes app and the links to for goodness gracious and all of all of that wonderful information. I do hope you check it out and try it out for your pets. And yeah, until next time, Amy, thank you so much. Thank you, Jessica.

56:28 Take care. Bye bye.

Amy Renz Profile Photo

CEO

Amy Renz is a courageous leader and advocate within the pet food industry. In 2009 she envisioned a planet with thriving companion animals, homes for the homeless ones, and respect for all beings; then she built a company committed to that purpose. Today Amy steers Goodness Gracious on its mission to craft and deliver human grade, nutritionally superior, species appropriate, whole food diets and treats for pets in a way that improves our connection to the planet and each other.

How does Goodness Gracious do that? It uses ethically sourced, sustainably harvested ingredients; green-energy on a path to net zero; less plastic, zero Styrofoam and more compostable materials; a vibrant culture of inclusion that celebrates diversity; and a charitable give-back to community animal causes amounting to half of its profits.

Whew.

With all that, what else is there? Amy also provides a voice for the silent. She writes and speaks about good nutrition, pet food industry shenanigans, holistic health, and the Goodness Gracious brand.

And for fun? Amy is Mama to a family of sixteen paws – three Forever Dogs and currently one fosters. She is a seven-time Marathoner, yoga junkie, cross fit athlete, and slalom water skier, who considers her biggest strength her indomitable spirit.