The Pet Parenting Reset
The Pet Parenting Reset
Question Everything. ReWild What Matters.
Conversations that challenge conventional pet care and help you raise healthier, happier pets by getting back to nature.
July 22, 2025

207. Identifying an Educator VS Influencer in the Holistic Pet Health Space with Raw Paw Adventures

207. Identifying an Educator VS Influencer in the Holistic Pet Health Space with Raw Paw Adventures
The Pet Parenting Reset
207. Identifying an Educator VS Influencer in the Holistic Pet Health Space with Raw Paw Adventures

There have been a lot of back and forth views lately in the holistic pet health space and we choose to give everyone grace to learn and grow and change their viewpoints.

That said, there is a big difference in an educator and an influencer and learning how to discern the information you're receiving from social media is a crucial part of life these days.

Kara from Raw Paw Adventures joins me on this weeks episode to discuss what we see, how we approach providing information and give some tips on how we see things in the space we love so much.

Send us a text

🐶 🐱 Nutrition & Holistic Health Consults: https://jessicalfisher.com/product-category/holistic-pet-health-nutrition/

💜 Follow Jessica on Instagram https://www.instagram.com/thepetparentingreset/

📩 Get email notifications for new episodes:
https://jessicalfisher.kartra.com/page/tpprnotify




0:01 Welcome back, pet parent. So today's episode is pretty cool. I haven't done this before, but we're actually doing a podcast. Swap. And if you're not familiar with what that is, it means we recorded together and we're listing it on both my podcast and her podcast. And I think out of every episode I have ever done, this may actually be one of the most important, which is saying a lot. I realize that is saying a lot because hopefully you continue to come back to the podcast and continue to learn from all the incredible experts that I bring to you, which obviously is why I do this. But let so you, if you've been here a while, you probably already know who Kara Hanrahan is. She's been on the podcast a couple of times. She's with Raw Paw Adventures, and her podcast is called Raw Now.

1:01 The reason why I think this episode was the episode to do this with, to have it go live on both my podcast feed and her podcast feed is because there's a lot going on. Well, there's a lot. Going on in the world. Obviously, but there's a lot going on in the holistic pet health space lately. And I hate using the word, the words misinformation and disinformation, but there is a lot of that going on just within the health community in general, especially like human health. To me, it is entirely to politicized food, health, nutrition, science.

1:50 None of this should be political, yet that's where we are in today's world. It is all politicized. And so Kara and I have decided. We did an episode on identifying an educator versus an influencer, specifically in the healthy pet space, the holistic pet space. And I think that this is just such an important topic. It's an important conversation to have because we have to. It's our responsibility. It's an added responsibility for us to have to vet the people that we listen to online and know who we choose to trust and who we choose maybe to just be entertained by, right or not listen to it all.

2:44 It's it's a new landscape. I mean, not new, new. Obviously we've had social media for a while now, but we're figuring this out as humans. And I'm not sitting here, neither is Kara saying like I'm the expert. Like, in fact, as you listen to this episode, you're going to understand why and how we feel like we're providing the best content we possibly can to our listeners. And in not saying that we're experts with all of the, you know, degrees and certifications that we have. And we have, we have different degrees care. As a nurse who has transitioned into functional medicine, my degree is my traditional bachelor's is in psychology with a focus in animal behavior. And but we have some of the same certifications moving forward as far as the holistic pet health space is concerned. And I think it's just a really important conversation for us to have.

3:50 So this intro is already way too long. Thank you for being here with me again. And make sure to check out the Raw Remedies podcast if you have not. Already done. So there we go. Hello. Thank you guys so much for joining us. By the way, this is I'm nervous. Dining with Dinah said. This is a salacious topic. I'm going with that word because it's sexy. Salacious. But I think this is an important enough topic that like for me, I was like, no, this is a no brainer. We need to put this out for like everybody to listen to. Yeah. And influencer versus educator, specifically in the healthy pet space. And I just want to, I know like I just read through all of your notes, Cara. And I just wanted to start out by saying that like, we're all human and we all make mistakes.

4:39 And I feel like it's our responsibility in this life to learn and grow. And so I'm never mad at anybody for learning and growing. I can be disappointed, certainly, but like, yeah, I think this is this is part of the human experience. And I just kind of wanted to start out by saying that before we. I agree. So like everybody, obviously we're all human. Well, I don't know. I barely consider myself an Earthling. I think sometimes I'm from Mars. But you know, it's, it's I kind of feel, and I said this the other day to Angela Arlino. I was talking to Angie and I said, if you're going to be an educator, you have to commit to always being a lifelong student.

5:20 The minute you stop learning is the minute you stop growing. And that is when you need to stop educating. And so I think my, my frustration here is it's one thing to and for we might need to like clarify for some people who are listening, but it's one thing to think that you knew something was one way and then to educate yourself and learn and grow and realize, oh gosh, it actually was more like this or, oh, I had more to learn. I didn't have the whole picture here. Let me let me like kind of come out and say like, oh, I learned more about this and I really grew in this area and I wanted to let you guys know that, you know, we, I, I wasn't quite there when I was talking about it last month, last year, whatever.

6:06 That's not what happened here. Or, or we get new studies, we get new science and we expand, right? Like that's right. That happens a lot. I mean, even for you and me, for sure. It's like, yes, look what we just found out, right? Like, yeah. Always new stuff coming on the market, always research is happening and always new evidence is popping up, whether that's anecdotal evidence or, you know, a peer reviewed double-blind placebo study that was done in a laboratory somewhere. But what we're just not super easy to find. Well, yeah, I know it's who's got the money for that. But what we're talking about today is a popular influencer brand. And I'm not going to drop names, but you know, they, they put out this very long video and actually a small part of me didn't even want to have this live or have this discussion because I don't want to give them any more views. I don't want to build their platform further. And I have no doubt that some people listening, if they haven't watched their video yet, they're probably going to go and watch it.

7:06 That's fine. But we're going to do a little bit of a breakdown. And it's kind of on my end, I think a little bit of rebuttals about some of the things that they said and some of the way they phrase things. And to be honest, in general, in my opinion, almost gaslit the entire holistic pet community. Yeah, it's like what it felt like. Yeah. So, yeah, well, and I think maybe it might be good to start with like what we what we see differently an educator versus an influencer. Like how, because I think influencer even I know there are definitely people like Rachel Cucero who like I called her an influencer one time and she was like, please don't. I don't want to do that.

7:50 Like that's not what I want to be. And I get that. And I think like influencer and content creator are seem interchangeable. And I feel like to be an educator, I don't think we talk about educators. I think they're just lumped into influencer or content creator as far as social media is concerned. And I think we should be able to tell to tell the difference because even in this very long video that we're talking about, that we're discussing today, the Doctor Who should have been an educator was very click baity was very extreme, was very. And it's like, yeah, we don't agree with him either. I don't know what.

8:33 Yeah, that wasn't, that was an interesting part of their video. And we'll get, we'll get to that eventually when we're kind of talking about the different stuff. But but you're right, unfortunately people who should be educators sometimes turn into influencers. And I don't think that might not be in and of itself a bad thing because sometimes when you're educating somebody, you are then influencing them to say like, hey, this brand of food encompasses all of the things that I've been educating you about and I recommend them or I use them. You could check them out. So perhaps they can go hand in hand. But I think what's been happening, what I've been seeing in our community lately is people who step into the space, who have good intentions for the most part, without really getting that kind of deeper breath of, of education and knowledge about a topic.

9:29 They see something, they get excited about it, they jump on it and they're like, this is the best thing since sliced cheese. Everybody needs to do it. And and that's kind of where the the problem lies, I think. Yeah, yeah. And I think also some of the problem is in just how our society is today. So a couple of things that I want to address about being a content creator or an influencer. It is not easy. It is a full time job and so you have to make money somewhere, right? Like you can't have a full time job, you can't have a fully functioning medical practice or veterinary clinic or whatever it may be and be really good at being an influencer or a content creator.

10:12 Like it's just. You can try and do both and then you can be like me and give yourself autoimmune thyroiditis. It's totally fine. Right, but that's the thing, like it is a full time job. So we have to kind of it goes both ways. Like I also hate when people are like, I hate that you're selling me something or I hate that you're recommending something. I'm never going to follow you again, right, because they they have to make a living too. So if you dedicate your time and energy, which would have to be full time or close to it, to educating people online, you have to have a way to make income. And like, as long as you are being up and up and like only recommending or selling products that you actually do believe in and you're not just taking any sponsorship that comes along.

10:56 I know for me, like having been in the space, even though I still can, like I'm, I'm a mic, whatever a micro influencer is, right? Like I'm small, but like I have turned down hundreds of people asking me to promote their product or talk about their product or I'll send you this product or I'll pay you to talk about like I have turned down hundreds just in the past couple of years because they don't align right, right. So like if you are, if you're on the up and up and you're only. So that is one thing. You have to be able to trust the person you're following that they're not gonna just be promoting whatever comes across their desk, right? That's one thing.

11:37 And I don't remember the second part of what I was gonna say, so there we go. That's OK. That's OK. So as we mentioned, for people who are listening live, we're gonna be posting this on our podcasts. So yes, for future podcast listeners. So for me, that's raw remedies, a raw remedies podcast for Jess, that's the pet parenting reset. So for our podcasters, you're going to hear us maybe have like a respond to a couple of comments that are on the live. So the healthy Pet nutrition commented and said, what's icky to me is that these influencers took advantage of many people and brands and then turned around and kind of gave them the middle finger, right? And I agree, I think that was, it's actually one of the points that they cover in their video.

12:18 And then she also said, And to say that there's no science behind the holistic modalities upside down :) for me, upside down :) means bullshit. Yeah. Yeah, yeah, I agree. And that was a big hot topic for me. Sorry. My cat's probably about to knock something over. That's OK. Was that like they kept saying like, there's no science here, There's no science here, And it's like, Oh my God, literally the science of natural medicine and holistic medicine existed before there was organized society. Like, don't tell me that there's no science. Right, right. Well, and I also think it's important to say that like I, you and I, I feel like we're both this way. I am very open to, I don't want to live in an echo chamber.

13:01 If you disagree with me, I'm OK with us having healthy conversation and agreeing to disagree. Like I'm totally OK with that. And I also think even in this video today or this podcast today, like there are going to be things that maybe Cara and I are not 100% in agreement with each other on. And like that's OK too because we have different learned experiences. We have lived through different things and she has an extensive like human medical background that I don't have. So we have very different experiences and we may not 100% agree. And I think like, I think it's very healthy for us to still have this conversation together and bring it to you so that you can see that like we don't always have to be 100% in agreement with each other to still respect each other and not gaslight each other and not.

13:56 I disagree with that. OK, that's fine by me. I'm just kidding. So, OK, So yes, 100%, I actually 100% agree with that. I don't disagree with that. There's probably going to be a few talking points that we maybe are are not on the same page about, and I think that's totally fine. And I think that we should kind of dive in and just start breaking some of this stuff down. Yeah. Yeah, let's do it. Yeah. And so, so Dog taught she. I just really quickly want to say she considers herself to be both an influencer and an educator. I would agree. I think we kind of talked about that a little earlier. She recognizes her limits as an educator. I, I, I feel the same way. This is why I have the podcast so that I can bring people to you that know things I don't.

14:39 I never collaborate with a brand. I wouldn't use very selective turn down brand deals all the time. Completely agree. Some people who purport to be educators lack the knowledge base to actually be educators, but they don't realize the limits of their knowledge. And I think that is the problem. Like not realizing your limitations. Exactly, and that was I had that problem when I first started here, which gave me like a big almost existential crisis where I had to step back and go, OK, I can't just apply everything human to animal. You need to do a little bit more digging. So and I think that kind of is a good lead into the first point that I want to make for this video. So bear with us guys, because this this video that we're kind of doing a breakdown was like 2 1/2 hours long and we're going to try and cram it until like an hour. But one of the biggest things for me was it kind of starts out saying like we built a brand and wrote a book and then went on a book tour.

15:37 And then we we started asking the hard questions and he had to unlearn everything that we had already learned. OK, that's what they said. That really disturbed me because you should never be going all in and spending so much time and money in reaching so many people and saying and recommending so many things. If you didn't already ask the hard questions. That is. That's how you steer people wrong. That's how you steer people wrong. That's called jumping on a fad or following the hype and doing signing up with brand deals and just getting the clicks and the likes and the follows rather than actually knowing the information inside and out before you put it out there for people to consume. So that's like how they kind of open their video explanation and I immediately was really disturbed by that. So, and apparently so, is Bear, if you can hear him barking. Yeah.

16:36 Well, and that's like, you know, and probably why it took us so long to get to do this video because I, it took me, it took me not 4 consecutive days, but the, the, when I sat down to watch this video, four whole days for me to get through the video because I would start and I would get so frustrated and like, I didn't want to have those feelings. I need to like I'm, I've been learning to actually feel my feelings again and like process them. And I, I would have to turn the video off. I'd have to pause it and be like, I will come back to this later. And, but that actually reminds me of the thing that I was going to say earlier is that in our society, right? Like they, this book deal was brought to them. And that, that was one of the things that bothered me. Like I was really happy for them when that happened because somebody like Rodney or Karen Rita Hogan with her herbal dog book, like they had to fight and fight and fight and fight to get their book published.

17:39 And this this book deal was brought to them. And I was so freaking happy for them for that. And it it's like A to me, OK, the forever dog did amazing. The forever dog like did amazing. The herbal dog has done amazing. So those are really great proof of concept that there is a market for these types of books. But the way the human brain works is that you can have like 20 amazing experiences and that one bad experiences is going to ruin all of it. And now like, I'm so curious how publishers are going to look at this. Yeah. And see this one bad experience. I worry that it's going to be like a, you know, one step forward, 2 steps back when something like this happens. I think you can really reverberate and backfire in a community like ours, which can be contentious and where we have so many big opinions and, you know, people with big brains and lots of knowledge. And, and you already, I think find it difficult not to fight amongst ourselves, which is frustrating in and of itself. But then when something like this happens, I, I almost feel like it's like the people waiting the in the wings who are now going, I told you so See, I knew it was bullshit, right? And I hate that because that's not what our community is about, right?

18:50 It really it's about building each other up and, and educating and just literally all we all want is for our animals to live better lives. And and I think you have these influencers want that too, right? They only ended up here because they wanted their dogs to live the longest, healthiest, best lives possible. And they still want that. It's just that I think the way they're going about things is just not the way I would do it. Oops, yeah. My cat's causing an earthquake. For me and and look again going back to like I'm not perfect. I don't know everything I I have put out video saying I was wrong. Yeah.

19:32 Two that I can think of off the top of my head, one of which I now I'm like, was I wrong? I don't know, like, like I'm because I keep learning because we keep getting new science, because we keep getting true, like real experts who spend their lives doing the research and studying the science, saying, you know, when we really put, we have these new studies or when we put these other studies together, like maybe, maybe, maybe this, maybe not. And, and I but I also think that's one of the things that is so difficult in every space. By the way, I think that, you know, allopathic western medicine really we've gotten, it's like checkbox medicine, right? Like that's where we are today.

20:15 And so they they have done a really, really good job in kind of indoctrinating us as a society to say everything fits in a box and when it doesn't. That hurts us so badly that we're like, we can't handle it, right, We can't handle it. But the reality of the whole world we live in is that nothing fits in a box. And I think that's one of the things that I conversations I know I had this weekend because we I just went to the more, you know, pet Wellness them and listening to some amazing speakers, though, who, by the way, Dr. Connor Brady gets up on stage and says, yeah, I'm constantly telling you guys that I was wrong because I learned something new. Look at Doctor Karen Becker. She's also a great example. Do you remember when she talked about how she was so sad that she had been recommending early spay and neuter, you know, 20 years ago and now?

21:02 Yeah, it took 20 years for us to realize the effects that that was causing to animals, right? She followed the best science that she had back then and, you know, just in terms of population control and all of the trouble that we were having in America 20 years ago. But things changed. The research came out, evidence was presented, and she went, damn, I need to update my practices. Hey guys, let me be transparent about this. That's the right way. That's the right way to say you've learned better. Right. What we're discussing that's the wrong way. But it wasn't. It was part of the conversation that we were having like privately, like in the with the speakers and the vendors and the sponsors like us behind.

21:43 Like after all the pet parents went home. I, I don't, that sounds weird. We're pet parents too. Like I'm not othering people. But like the conversations we were having were like, I get why this is so hard for a lot of people because even amongst us, even in one day where we brought 5 speakers together and I don't know, 10 vendors, like we are in one day telling pet parents contradictory information from the stage right between the speakers. There's contradictory information. And like I think all of the speakers, all of the people that we know and love are really good about saying this is what I currently believe. But also there's room like we never, I think we try really hard to never come out saying it's black and white. We always come out saying this is what I'm currently believing based on the research, but everything is Gray, right? And I think that's not what happened in this video. Yeah, I agree.

22:50 You know, it's funny, they kind of they kind of make it clear that they have a bit of a black and white mentality also very close to being of the video. Because another thing that they mention is when they first kind of realized that this was the space that they wanted to step into and they had all of these, you know, truth bombs coming at them about things that they had never thought of before. One of the things that they did is like a complete almost kind of like a health cleanse and, and gave themselves an incredibly restrictive diet, which, you know, allowed them to feel healthier and lose a lot of weight. But they felt like it was completely unsustainable and overly restricting and kind of tout that as being like a negative of like being in the space and kind of like following, well, almost like following other influencers, right.

23:35 And I completely agree that sounds very restrictive. But that's also not what the holistic pet spaces is recommending people do. We are recommending A healthier way of life, yes, but that way of life shouldn't be restricting or unsustainable. As a matter of fact, I don't think that I have heard anybody speak to the importance of feeding fresh food without talking about how to make it sustainable in a long time. I mean everything when I'm talking about I have, you know, experts on or nutritionists on or even on my website. I have a whole. I spent almost, I don't even know, 2-3 weeks combing through the Internet to find as many co-ops by state as possible in compiling that onto a web page for people like the people in this space want everyone to succeed.

24:29 Yeah. You know, if we didn't, we wouldn't be here and also we'd be out of a job. I mean, not I'm not called a job, but like for a lot of people, this is our job. And if, if we couldn't make this sustainable for people, if it was like, haha, chump got you and then move on to the next every single time. I'm sorry, where do you think we would be? This is millions of people that come back over and over and over and are continuing to do this lifelong. So making things unsustainable sounds like more of a personal problem, not something that the holistic space stands for. Yeah, I, I completely agree with that. And also it's really easy to look at the extremes on either side and say, because they scream at us, right?

25:12 The majority of the population is pretty quiet. It's those extremes that are so loud all the time. And I think that's what I saw a lot of in this video was the extremes, the the and because I've seen it too, I've heard it too. You shouldn't, you shouldn't be allowed to own a dog if you can't afford to feed them a species appropriate diet. Like I would never say that to anybody because you know what a fed dog is better than a starving dog. And like a dog in a loving home is better than a dog on the street, right? Like you do the best you can. I mean, I think that is something that we all have had to learn also can I think a lot of us, maybe not all of us, but a lot of us start out with like, no, we have to do it this way because this is the right way and this is what works. And then we kind of learn really quickly, hopefully that like you're not, you're not going to get very far that way because that is unsustainable.

26:11 So bringing in the extremes that the extremes are unsustainable. And unfortunately, the extremes, you're right, are the ones that tend to shout the loudest, but they're also the ones that I think are easy enough to go all right. Well, that person's maybe being a little bit of a zealot about this and we need to just. For sure, yeah. They can be, they might be the loudest, but sometimes they're the easiest to ignore and you can just put the upside down :) and go about your day. Right. And I do think, I do think some of it, and I like reading through some of your notes on, on the video, like I'm probably jumping all around here, but like there definitely are creators and influencers. I don't think educators. I think educators are the ones most frustrated with the algorithms because we are so against doing click baity things. Like we might try them in a very subtle way here and there, like learning that you've got to catch somebody's attention in the first 3 seconds by saying something. You know what I mean?

27:09 Like we try to do those things because we want people to see the content and hear the content and realize that like there's more there than just the click bait. But a lot of creators and influencers especially are very click baity. So could I think of an instance where I would want somebody to eat a piece of chocolate over an apple maybe, Right. If it's like organic dark chocolate, fair trade whatever versus like a non organic apple covered in a peel, maybe I would want you to eat. In glyphosate just prior to to consuming it, yeah. Maybe I would want you to eat the chocolate versus the apple.

27:52 It's like Snow White 2 point O an apple. Yeah, yeah. Oh. My God, no, I, I yes, I I know what you're saying. Sometimes it feels like you are capitulating to get someone to watch. And yeah, because it is frustrating at the end of the day. And you know what? I have cried. I'm not ashamed. I have cried to you, Jess, to my husband many times. My poor husband. He's a St. about how I spend so much time and effort. First, educating myself. Second, turning that education into content. Excuse me, Goose. Sorry. My cat decided it would be a great time to step right in front of the camera. So make it, getting the education, putting it into a format that I think people will like taking the time to like upload it to each social or to, you know, make it into a Canva presentation or whatever, record it, whatever it is, and then put it out there for the world to see.

28:48 And you get like three people to view it. And you're like, well, that's cool. I spent 30 hours on this. It's frustrating, it's exhausting, and it's not fair. It's not fair when you see people like this, people who catapulted themselves to fame by saying the right things and making click baity videos and following all the trends just to pull the rug out from under 1,000,000 followers according to what they say in their video and be like, actually, we didn't really mean most of that. Like it's infuriating. Yeah, it is. It is very frustrating and I get a tangent. You know, you're good. Like it's, it's, it's the reality of where we are and it's the reality of society that like we can't, we can't sit and watch a 20 minute video anymore, right? Like if you can't catch my attention in three seconds, I've got no time for you.

29:41 Right? Like that. It's, it sucks. We've allowed it to happen, right, with advertising and video games, and I mean with social media in general, like it's very much, you know, a slot machine very much like that's what they're designed to be is each one of these platforms is like, how can we get better at being that slot machine that you can't walk away from? That's the whole point of social media platforms. So, you know, trying to figure out and I think that's, that is one of the really I and I cried. I cried watching the video we're talking about. And I remember texting you when I felt like the I forced myself to sit there the last like 30 minutes of the video without stopping it. And I was just, I was bawling, crying because one, mostly for the pet parents that are going to see that video and think that now they're doing everything wrong.

30:31 Yeah. When I don't think they are, I don't think they are. I agree. I'm very afraid that this is going to either turn people off from the community because they're going to feel like things are too divisive or that we're wishy washy or that people are going to take what they say to heart to the detriment of their pets. And I, I really hope that's not what happens. Yeah. You know what another one of the points that gets made in this video is, And I think I actually quoted it in my notes, it was said, quote, those who spread misinformation often aren't aware of it. They actually believe they're doing what's best for them and other people. End Quote. I agree, that's very true. What's not true is to apply that quote to the holistic community as a whole. That is very wrong.

31:17 Yeah. You know, and it aggravates me because they keep talking about how holistic modalities aren't aren't backed by science. Or they talk about how like one of the big points that they make is how they were all gung ho about raw milk for a long time and that they were considering doing just like drinking only raw milk for like a month to do a reset and then pulled back and realized that they pulled back and realized that that that they weren't going to. I'm I'm pretty sure I and I can't, you know, say quotations again, but they said something along the lines of we realized that that wasn't going to give us the nutrients that we need. And it's like. You know, because we eat off of a spreadsheet every day. Exactly, I just had a podcast episode on raw Romney's podcast with the amazing Roxanne Stone of solutions pet product. She's products.

32:09 She's amazing and we talked about raw milk restorative diets. There is literally I where did I I even I put it up here on my thing. This since the 90s, doctors, physicians at the Mayo Clinic, which is one of the most famous clinics in America, have used raw milk to help reset and restore chronic gut conditions, autoimmune conditions, all kinds of things, allergies. There is so much data about raw milk and how it helps people when they're younger and can also help when you're older. And a lot of that has been applied to animals to just throw that out casually and be like, well, we realized it wasn't giving us the nutrients we need. Please Jesus, it explained to me how we feed babies nothing but raw milk for like 12 months of life and they grow into tiny humans.

33:04 Can you please explain that to me? And it builds their immune system. It literally builds their immune system. Like that? There's a reason why we use it for restorative diets. I mean I do this with my clients all the time. It does that mean me that that that was rough because the reality is the reality is that the majority of milk production in this country is in industrialized lot raised cattle. And to me, I would never drink that milk raw like that no, so it I would I would very much like that to be the inverse. I would, I would love for the majority of milk on the market to be raw and I would love for the majority, all cattle to be raised regeneratively and naturally.

33:54 That's not where we are. So no, like if you go into a, you know, an industrial ranch, I would not drink that milk raw. No, all you need to do is drive by it on the highway and you can smell why you would never want to drink or eat any of that product. So, yeah, terrifying. Yeah. Yeah. But that's, you know, that's not what we're talking about. We're talking about raw. Like true, safe raw with amazing requirements. And for anybody who's listening, check out Raw Farms in California. And Mark McAfee is the owner and founder of Raw Farms. He's phenomenal. I have met him in person. I've interviewed him on my podcast. I went to his ranch, I saw how his cows were raised.

34:34 I saw his facility. I saw how they test every single batch multiple times for pathogenic organisms. I mean, I literally saw their laboratory. The ones that are doing it right are doing it right. And those that's, that's how you do a restorative diet, right. So raw cow milk from them, raw goat milk from, you know, green juju solutions. Now they have the sheep nog solutions. I mean, they have, they're doing it right. Asian has ruined the dairy industry unfortunately. I mean so much.

35:14 It created a lot of controversy and I don't think that's something that's ever going to change. And also we could probably spend like 45 minutes on just that alone. But but that was one of the points that got me. I know the most riled up, if you couldn't tell by how riled up I just got again. I, I had, I had a couple of other moments that got me just as riled up not to actually. Before we go into it, I just want to read a couple of these comments on from the live. SO 4 rooted Plas mentioned in my eyes, they've lost all their credibility. I agree. And to be honest, last year even before they came out with the whole we don't recommend raw milk anymore, I saw that they started doing affiliate, affiliate links with the farmer's dog. That was that was the moment for me. That was it for me because I know what's in the farmer's dog formulations and it's not something that I would recommend I.

36:04 Would recommend it's it's fresh formulated as kibble. Yeah. Like that's how I see it. Lots of seed oils, lots of potatoes and peas and things that our dogs don't need. So as soon as I saw that partnership, I was like, I see what's happening here. It's where can I make the most money? So that really that's kind of when it flew out the window for me. Dining with Dina. That's a cute name said. I say we just thank, thank them for showing us who they really are and hope that we've all learned a valuable lesson. Be careful who you take advice from. I agree. I agree. Oh hi to Sonia. Sonia from raw pets food is here. I love raw pets. That's where I order a lot of my food from. She's amazing. Dog Tot said. I didn't watch the entire video, but from what I did watch I didn't think their views changed that drastically, framing the change as drastic as click bait itself. I.

36:52 Agree, they definitely made a title that was kind of click bait Yi think to try and get as many people to click as possible. But they definitely have drastically changed their views. Because to say I went from drinking all raw milk to saying we don't trust raw milk anymore, saying that, you know, they went all in on vet visits, no vaccines, no flea chemicals, only raw. And now they're pulling back and saying like, we still believe in fresh, but we don't think raw is best. And we we thought that vaccines were the devil and now we know that's not true. And it's like they really, they swung from extreme to extreme. It's all about the conversation for each thing. Yeah.

37:35 So it's it's not that some of the views that they're presenting right now I think is wrong. I agree raw isn't for every pet. Fresh food in general is just better. But it doesn't have to be raw. Yeah. Just like a lot of points that they made. But the biggest point, the biggest problem is that they did so much gas lighting and made it seem like there's no science here, that we don't back up what we say and that we're all just influencing people. And, and we'll get to, I have another point later. I think that will kind of solidify some of those things. So I'll come back to that. But OK, I think that was that was most of them. Oh, dining with Gina said I never found them credible. I asked many of my friends what even made them experts on anything.

38:15 Same. And I personally never thought they were experts on anything. I mean, I don't consider myself an expert on anything either, but I was pretty darn happy with the reach they were getting for the message that I do believe in. Yeah. So that's where I was like, yeah, if you don't. Have the reach. It doesn't matter what you say, no one's there to hear. It I mean, I think, I think they're going to, I think they'll probably keep some of their audience, especially the people who aren't in this, like if those were the only influence influencers they were following about holistic health. If they didn't get into and start looking into anybody else or following anybody else, they'll probably keep those people and sadly transition them back. In my opinion, sadly transition them back. But I do think they're going to have to build a whole new audience.

39:06 Yeah, and I'm sure they'll find it. Yeah, I'm sure they'll. No, they're, it's out there. I mean, PetSmart and Chewy and Petco and Banfield and VC, like they're thriving for a reason, right? You know what I mean? Like the audience is there for sure. Banfield makes me cringe. Makes me cringe. All right, What? You were going to make a point about one of the things in the video that bothered you. So so many things bothered me honestly. Like I didn't quote anything here, but to say herbs in nature aren't designed by scientists and they aren't studied for health. Like that's what I took from it from one of the first things they they mentioned, like and just being in the space, I could tell who they were targeting all along the way.

39:52 And that bothering me too. But like, yeah, like whatever you believe in God, the universe guy, like whatever you want to call it, the earth gives us so much like if we and humans have destroyed it. One of the one of the things that it just popped in my head, Connor talked about, I think this was just like at the coffee talk yesterday, but he said. No, it might have been on stage. He was like, if you zoom out to like a world view, whatever you believe in a creator or the universe or whatever, and we say, what is what's a pathogen? And you look at the Earth, humans are the pathogen. Yeah, right. You know what I mean? So like that it was absolutely humans are the pathogen, humans are the weed, humans are the pathogen, humans are the ones that are but without us. Like if we take, if we take away what we have done to the Earth since industrialization, if we go back before industrialization, we can look and see that the Earth gave us everything we needed, just not in anybody's financial interest, right, To keep it that way.

40:57 That's that's that's what I see. That's how I see it. Yeah, I think I, I think I remember Doctor Connor talking about that a little bit at the International Naturally Healthy Pets conference. He was talking about like, what is a pathogen? What makes something a pathogen? I really like that reference because you're right, we have kind of turned and burned the world since we've been on it. But, you know, now I think it's a bit more synergistic, right? It would exist without us, but I guess we can't exist. With us. True. Very true. We need to just do a little bit better to keep our hosts in good health. Right, yeah, so Millie's Real Life asked a question, Healthy Pet Nutrition kind of answered, but I want to jump into it just really quickly. Millie's real Life says how do you feel about the effectiveness of homeopathy?

41:38 I know there's not much info and studies on it for pets. Healthy Pet Nutrition says homeopathy has been around forever. Doctor Richard Pitt Karen is a great resource. My understanding about homeopathy, which is pretty limited, though I have had multiple homeopathic veterinarians on my podcast to talk about it, is that we knew for ever that homeopathy worked. Hanneman, I think, was the originator. Is that right of homeopathy? Doctor Hanneman, I believe nothing about homeopathy. It's one of the things that I'm actually very intimidated about and can't wait to learn more about in the future. I'm I'm intimidated about it to even after having talked to so many people about it, it still intimidates me to try to use it like I'm not. I will not practice with it. I will not.

42:20 I don't know anything near enough to recommend. Like, that's one of my limitations, right? I know that's a limitation I have. So Hanneman, I believe, was the name of the doctor that originated the homeopathy. We knew so much that it worked so well. The majority of hospitals in the US used to be homeopathic hospitals. And then was it, was it Rockefeller? So he also was very much, he knew and believed in and wrote about the power of homeopathy. But once he started making all of his money through oil and found out through oil and and then petroleum and now pharmaceuticals being petroleum based, he very effectively went out and said no more homeopathy, killed all the homeopathic hospitals to promote petroleum based pharmaceuticals. This is this was very intentional for you. 100 years later, 100 + 3 years later, to not even think that homeopathy has basis in science.

43:23 No, it absolutely does. It absolutely does. We just have to remember it and find it again. I just don't know enough about it, but it's something that I definitely plan on adding to the toolbox one day once I get more confident with the other things that I'm already using. Right thing at a time, right? Not a little bit of this, a little bit of that. Not dabbling. I'm diving so right. Can't dive into one until you finish swimming through the other. And then Librella. I was. So I wasn't even sad about Librella. I was angry. About it, I need to like go lay down and like curl into a ball like I can't with the librella. I was angry about the librella. So they made a.

44:04 They made a comment about so they mentioned librella and like how senior dogs might have better quality of life if they take that librella and that pet parents have no business shaming someone for giving it to their dog even if it means that the dog ends up with issues down the line because of taking the librella. They were making a case that like if it helps them now, even if it causes problems down the line, they shouldn't be shamed. That is bullshit. Well, that. Takes me mad no? Yes but I I don't believe in shaming people. I agree with the don't shame people part, yes I agree. Don't shame people, but. However. Educate people. It's not about shaming. It's about educating. You don't you don't say like, well, it's OK if you do this even though it's going to cause kidney failure later. As long as they can get up and walk around for two weeks. No, that's not what we do here.

44:55 We say let's look into these multiple holistic and natural modalities that don't have side effects like that, that aren't going to potentially end your pets life sooner just because it gave them a few weeks of relief. Once we learned what this drug was doing to animals, the outcry should be echoing across the mountain tops. So should anyone be shaming ever? No, but it's not. I don't know, I just was really disturbed by them. Saying my issue is not at all with pet parents giving Labrella and Silencia to their dogs and cats. My issue is with the lack of informed consent in the veterinary industry. So I mean in the, in the human medical industry as well, but we're we're talking about there, there is no, I don't know what we get.

45:42 What do we get informed consent on when we go to the veterinarians office? Like, I don't even know, maybe. Surgery, that's about it because you have to sign for it. But no, I agree. My own animal is the exact same example. Bear got cytopoint for years. Never one time was I told about risk factors associated with cytopoint. Never was I given information about adverse effects. Never was I given the insert in the package for this shot, not even when I had to come back sooner and sooner in between each shot, not realizing why that was happening and why it wasn't lasting as long for him. Zero information. It was literally offered to me as a miracle drug. Your dog has allergies. Well, we can give him this and his symptoms are going to go away. So.

46:26 And that's unfortunately what happens with a lot of these pharmaceuticals, Librella included and that one. Yeah, pretty scary. It's it for me it is. It is all about informed consent. Because yes, if you have a 17 year old dog who can barely walk, but you just feel it in your heart that they're not ready to go yet, then OK, If this is something you want to try and you understand what the risks are, OK. But on a four year old dog, we don't even know the extent of what nerve growth factor does in the body. So we don't know the extent of what the the risks are. Yeah, I got, you're right. Like you said, nothing is black or white. And I could make a case that maybe if you want to set up home euthanasia services, right.

47:12 Or maybe you have some kids at college and you want them to be able to come home and say, you know, goodbye or or maybe you really are only hoping for another two weeks, two months. Yeah. Yeah. OK. I could see, I could see reaching for that fix momentarily. Momentarily. Not if you want yours left with your animal, because you're not going to get it if you give this. I don't know, but yes. I agree, but pet parents don't know that. Yeah, yeah. Yes, and no one's telling it to them except the Internet after something has happened to their pet, because why else would they look until it's unfortunately too late? Yeah, yeah.

47:53 Well, it's also so telling to me that like they they put is it Zoetis that puts out Elborella? I don't even know around the world, other countries have the disclosure and we had to fight to get the disclosure in our pamphlets in our product packaging. So this. Was the point that I was going to make earlier. And then I wanted to wait in this in this lovely video that we're we've been talking about now for 45 minutes, they reference a different video, an interview between a Doctor Gundry, who's a cardiologist and Doctor Mike, who's a family physician. Now, Doctor Mike is one of those people on the Internet that I would say is both an educator and an influencer. He's very well known.

48:39 He's very handsome. He has a giant Newfoundland named Bear who is like a walking pillow. OK. I enjoy Doctor Mike. Doctor Mike. Too I watch some of his videos. Yeah, Doctor Mike reaches a lot of people and he's doing the things right. He knows how to make YouTube content and he's famous for it. So. But in that content, his true goal and his passion is education. And to be honest, I actually didn't even look up this Doctor Gundry guy afterwards. I probably should have to see like what he actually stands for. But essentially what was he going on about Jesse? He was talking about how like fruits and vegetables are like bad for you or something. Like he made a, he made like one random statement like apples are poison or something. Yeah.

49:25 Well, in that psychologist trying to be a nutritionist, even though we all know that in traditional medical school we don't get nutrition education. So there's that. So, but I think, I do think he is trying to be an influencer and kind of hopping on some of the bandwagons because Gundry, it is Gundry. Gundry, yes, Doctor Gundry. Because it is true that the fruits and vegetables we have today are genetically modified. They are not the fruits and vegetables that humans would have been eaten. Yes, most of them. Or dipped in pesticides. Or, you know, like grown in soil that's depleted in nutrients. True. Yes, true. Yeah. So it's not that his argument isn't rooted in truth, He's just taking it to an extreme to get people's attention. Yeah, as he also answers.

50:18 He also was using like kind of like disarming language. So essentially the reason why the influencers that we're talking about use this video as an example is because this doctor Gundry, who is not a nutritionist, he's not certified as a nutritionist. He's a cardiologist. He made some admittedly kind of outlandish, outrageous statements about like nutrition and about eating fruits and vegetables, things like that. He was talking about like this pathway essentially. I think the whole thing that sparked the conversation was he was saying like it's OK to smoke cigarettes because nicotine is good for you. Because he tried to say that like nicotine becomes nicotinic acid which is vitamin B3 and like you want your whatever.

51:00 Yeah, yeah. He just like, goes down this ridiculous pathway and Doctor Mike is trying to corner him and make him say, essentially make it clear that he's full of shit. Yeah, yeah, he was. He was. And. He was, he was. This is a stupid video. He is full of shit. I can't even believe that he would let Doctor Mike interview him knowing that he was going to completely pick him apart. But the point of this is, is, you know, in this video, they're saying that Doctor Gundry used like disarming language and red flag language and specific tactics to like disarm and reroute people to make it seem like he knew what he was talking about when he actually had no idea.

51:42 And that video, those tactics, that is what they're saying the holistic community and holistic vets are doing. They're saying that we are using red flags and specific tactics to like, make pet parents think that there's more evidence or more science or we know more about a topic than we actually do because we're using fancy language and essentially fooling them. And I was just so disappointed that they would take such an obvious example of somebody really skewing the science and making outrageous statements and then try and say that that's how we as the holistic community act and tried to like, make money off of pet parents.

52:24 I was just really grossed out by that. Yeah, and I I completely like I don't out of anybody in the holistic pet space that uses tactics like that. I'm just gonna go with wherever you're pointing in a finger. Therefore going back 3 going back to you. That's probably the worst thing that I'm gonna say on this whole whole live. But this is this is exactly like an average person who has no bandwidth that are just they're, they're getting through their life, right? They are, And I, I feel it too. They're getting through their life. They're working their 9 to 5 or whatever. They're working there maybe two or three jobs in this economy. I have no idea.

53:05 They're just trying to do the best for their kids and for their pets. They don't have the bandwidth to really research things. You see clips, you see reels and Tik Toks and you're like, oh man, yes, that this type of content really sucks for those people. But this is also, and I was going to say I was going to bring this up before you brought in gundry, but I think this is a better place to bring in gun to bring this in. Is that I just felt so many political undertones in this whole video in this whole 2 1/2 hours and this this is this is a point where I was like, Oh yeah, this is very political because COVID was politicized and by politicizing COVID, we have now politicized our whole healthcare system.

53:49 And you're either right or wrong. You believe or you don't believe and you know, I don't care what you think. They bring in RFK Junior. So I don't care what you believe or you don't believe about RFK Junior. Maybe it's too much for you. Maybe. Yeah. And and like we all do change our minds. We all do learn and grow. So bringing up a 20 year old interview or 10 year old interview with somebody verse in saying see, they've changed their minds. So you can't you can't trust them. We all change our minds. That's the point. We all live and learn and grow and, and like there's new research and we, we open ourselves up to that new, like you have to open. If you're not opening yourselves up to new information, then you're not going to grow.

54:35 I don't want to stagnate. I don't want other people to stagnate. I don't think it's beneficial for them or for their pets to just stay stagnant. So like I had a problem with all of that. I have an issue with politicizing health and I felt that so deeply. Like it was just like this, like hum underneath everything in the video that felt so political to me. Yeah, I think I didn't notice that or like I guess see it quite in that light. Although now that you've mentioned a couple of those things, I agree. I can see, I can see where you're coming from. And I have a feeling that you and I probably have different opinions on a few things just like we did, like what you're explaining, which also again, is totally fine. But whether or not that influenced where they were coming from with all of this, I don't know. It could have partially influenced, could have been a big influence or could have had nothing to do with it. And they just wanted to like use these as examples to like pull them in, maybe partially because those things in and of themselves are hot topics that are that like make people watch and react and share and comment, right? So like the more, again, it's all about the algorithms. So I don't know.

55:46 Yeah. Well, and that does, I don't know there is there were so many other things like between Gundry and RFK that like we I know I had made notes about but and I do think that does bring us to, but that does bring us to a topic where I do think we I think we agree, but not 100% which is on vaccines. And I do feel like they definitely change their minds big time on vaccines. They call vaccines treat prevention in the video. OK, so I wrote a note. Tell me if this makes sense to you and if this is actually the part where you're at. So I had put a note in here. It's #18 of 30 guys, I made 30 walking points about this video #18 was like using the clips of RK Junior and the clips of him saying that unvaccinated kids are bright or smarter, more engaged, blah, blah, blah.

56:35 And they feel like this is very insane mantra essentially. And my own personal opinion, I'm not afraid to put it on here, is that I do think that that's kind of over the top, some of those statements that he made. I think that it's really unfair for people who live with autism and and like make a, like a, a life and they have jobs, they have thoughts, they have opinions, they have love, spouses, children, right? I think to make broad statements like blanket statements will never do you well in health. I agree with. That absolutely. And so I do think that like some of the some of the approaches being taken are like a little bit over the top. And I personally do not feel like I am educated enough or have read enough research in the human realm to be able to take a stance about vaccine, vaccine, vaccines and autism. I cannot say one way or the other. Yes, I believe this or no I do not. And I won't because I would be foolish to do so without having educated myself enough about it.

57:30 But what I can say about vaccines for dogs and cats, for our companion animals is that there is no precedence for the ridiculous standards that are set about vaccines for animals. And there is no reason why a 10 LB Chihuahua versus a 200 LB Newfoundland should be getting the same dose of rabies vaccine every year when we have science that shows us that you continue to mount an immune response against rabies for upwards of seven to 10 years. Literally, blood tests will prove it to you. And there's no reason why veterinarians should be able to get tighter testing and not get a booster unless their titer test shows that they don't have appropriate enough immune response.

58:17 And they do that if they get like bitten, scratched or whatever, that's that are exposed to potential rabies, don't get rabies vaccines every year or every three years. They just don't. So why is that appropriate for humans? But we can't use that science on pets. And it's about money. And unfortunately, that in and of itself is politicized, which is really like frustrating, but. I can tell you guys. Too. It's the same thing for people. If I get a healthcare provider in my emergency department who got a needle stick, it happens. I've had a needle stick before. We draw their blood and we check and see if their hepatitis B titer is still active. If you show that you have immunity to hepatitis B, you don't get a booster. If you show that you don't have an immune response to hepatitis B anymore, you get a booster. Why?

59:02 Because you just stabbed yourself with a needle from somebody who has hepatitis B and you don't want to get hepatitis B. But we don't just give it to you without checking, right? We check. Why do we do that for vets? Why do we do that for healthcare providers? But why do we not do it for animals? There's no reason other than money. I agree. Well, and I actually, I mean, I actually agree with all of your statements. They're like, I don't know near enough to say one way or the other on like vaccines and humans and autism. I I I do agree that it's that we should look into it though. Like, I don't, I don't think we can. You research. Exactly. That's you're gonna, that's where I'm at with it. Like it's not absurd to ask the question and research it. Yeah, yeah.

59:50 If there's a question, if you're not sure, if the science doesn't make sense, if the trail doesn't track, then you look into it, right. If the studies, you know, if we, if everything that we're doing right now is based off of a very small subset of studies like 5 of them that were done in the 80s. Well, maybe there does need to be more research. I agree. Don't stagnate, right? We've said that multiple times here. Yeah. So I do think that there always is room for more research. Always. Yeah, and, and I think there's more, I think there's room for more research with dog and cat vaccines as well. You know, they tried to do the, was it the the rabies challenge study?

1:00:31 And I mean, the reality is what you have to do to these animals to to complete these studies is horrific. And we don't want to do it. Yeah, right. I get that too you. Don't want to inject an animal with the rabies vaccine and find that some of them actually end up getting rabies? We don't want that. Yeah, yeah. But is there a different way? I don't know. I don't know either and it is it's it's unfortunate that we can't take what we do now, like you just said, that we can measure the immune response through a blood draw. Yeah, just tighter I. Don't know. Just do that. Just do that. It's not. That hard? It's not that hard. I'm moving actually, if you if I pointed my camera literally anywhere else in this room right now, it would look like an explosion happened. But our moving our moving truck, our pods that we have to load up comes in four days.

1:01:23 And I I saved this section for last to be broken down so that we can do our Live Today. Oh my goodness. So it looks nice but actually I'm surrounded by chaos. Chaos. But I'm moving back to New York in just a few weeks and I need to find a new vet And I'm so terrified that I am not going to be able to find a vet that is going to accept titers. I was very lucky to have found an integrative vet here that lets me tighter my animals and very scared to go home and have to get established with a new vet and have them tell me that my 3 geriatric cats need a rabies or my dog who has a history of pancreatic issues needs a rabies booster. Or my dog with a history of leaky gut and environmental sensitivities needs a rabies booster. Right.

1:02:09 I don't want to give that to my animals who either are geriatric or have had health conditions that's not what their immune system needs. So it's it's frustrating when you know the education doesn't match like the actual legitimate science. And I don't know without being a lawmaker, I don't know where that. Comes from, yeah. But I think our point about this was that they swung from no vaccines ever their devil to vaccines are preventative. So actually we should be getting them. And there's no evidence to to there's no true scientific evidence to show that vaccines can cause problems. Yeah. Well, which I I also think is a very extremist view to begin with, right. Like that is to say no vaccines ever. And yes, there are people, there are veterinarians or excuse me, not practicing because they can't say it. If they're practicing, if they have a current license, they cannot say no vaccines.

1:03:03 But there are people who were veterinarians who say no vaccines ever. And who got in big trouble for it and elected it? Elected to forgo their license, Yeah. Because they felt so strongly that that was not a part of their Do no harm. Yes. Well, and there are no sods and there are, there are other ways to create, you know, a healthy immune system that has appropriate response to certain certain things. This is, again, my limitation. It's out of my purview. I haven't done it. I can't talk to it. I had Brie Drake on the podcast recently. She did it with her most recent dog. No sods.

1:03:44 So no sods. Yeah. I really don't know enough about it and I want to but I don't. Yet, right, right. I mean, I, I send everybody to doctor Will Falconer, I'm like, there you go. That's that's, that's the under. Yep, that's beyond my capabilities at the moment. But yeah, I, I just think that again, it's, it's not allowing yourself to live in the Gray. And I think if you don't allow yourself to, if, if you do take this as a very black and white, and if you have that black and white perspective and you can't live in the Gray, then you are going to burn yourself out and you are going to feel like it's unsustainable. And I, yeah, I think that maybe that's where they wound up because there was a lot of talk about none of this being sustainable.

1:04:31 And the idea that the average pet parent can't do this because it's not sustainable bothered me because there are average pet parents everywhere doing this. Like, yeah, maybe it's still a small percentage of the dog and cat population in the USI can only speak to the USI have no idea what's going on the rest of the world, But they are doing it. They are doing it. So it it takes sure. Is it going to take more? But guess what? Gen. Z's are not having babies anyway. Like there's a whole movement of like, nobody wants kids anymore. OK, great. They're all treating their kid, their pets as kids. If that's what you want to do, great. So then you do have the bandwidth to do this with your pets, right? I don't know this again stream of consciousness that I have about it.

1:05:18 I think maybe like a couple more points before we hop off or let's see, I had something about their website, I think. Yeah, the one of the phrases that they use that pissed me off was that they said, quote, I literally drank the Kool-aid, Yeah, when they were talking about raw milk and the. Holistic raw space. I was like, oh, that's. Cool. Tell me. Yeah, tell me more about kool-aid. All I can think about is like the kool-aid man, like bursting into their house. Do you? Remember the seeing all that? Yeah, you're the. Kool-aid man. I just all I see all I hear in my head when I hear that is like the the cult leader guy, the like. Oh God, yeah. Yeah, which I think was the reference that he was making. I don't believe this is AI. Don't.

1:05:59 Know I'm a part of the Jeep community. You want to see a a cult? Go join the deep community. We're a bunch of psychos. I was going to say, you want to start a cult, Kara? Let's. Hell yeah I do. Let's start a cult. Start a call. I'll start one. I would be terrible at it. A bias. Let's talk about bias. One of their complaints was that companies who sell raw milk and share information about the safety of raw milk have no business doing so because they don't warn about bias about their potential bias. Anytime you make and sell something, you assume there's personal bias there, right? I made this, I'm selling it to you. I am biased that it works and it's healthy and I want you to purchase it from me.

1:06:43 I personally don't think that you need to make a disclaimer about personal bias for the product that you're selling. Now, on the other hand, if you are an influencer or an educator or somebody who does not make or work for that company, but you make a profit from helping to sell that company's product, that is bias that you should disclose. And the best way that I can explain this is if anybody has ever watched like an educational video webinar. And I mean, I've watched a bajillion of them over my career in healthcare. At the beginning of these educational videos, it starts with an introduction.

1:07:28 I'm doctor so and so I'm nurse practitioner, nurse practitioner, blah, blah, blah. These are my disclaimers. And they will say if they have stake in any companies or if they have ownership of any companies or if they make compensation from any companies that they might mention in their lecture. So there's a difference between I believe in raw milk. So I own a dairy farm and I practice good practices to bring you this healthy product. Or I'm an influencer who gets 10% of whatever you buy because you used my affiliate link. Right.

1:08:09 There's a, there's a, there's a big difference there. And also, you know that saying that like when somebody criticizes you about something, it's because that's what they fear in themselves. Yeah. Like that's just the vibe that I'm getting again, like I don't want to be like super Debbie Downer. Like, yes, we are allowed to change our minds. And yes, we're, I think it's just we were attacked. Like when we get closer to the end of the video, like we were attacked. And I, I feel like, I mean, we've had this conversation so many times where like you have such an extensive medical, human medical background that like it feels a lot of people, how do I want to say this?

1:08:55 Like there's a lot more credibility in what you're saying versus what I'm saying. And I can realize that and I'm not, I'm fine with that. But like, I don't know if that's. True. Though a lot of people, well a lot of people feel that way and I can acknowledge that and not feel threatened by it. Like I can support you and lift you up because like I know that you're to me, I think you're doing a good thing and not feel like threatened by that. But like I guess all that to say like that, we do share a couple of certifications and those certifications were attacked. Yeah. And, and there's things that you might say like I'm not comfortable with, go to this person.

1:09:38 And it's the same thing for me. Like for example, if somebody came to me and they wanted me to help them DIY raw cat food, I'd be like, oh, I'm so sorry. Here's my friend Jess's contact information because I have no idea how to do that. I can recommend 3 or 4 excellent pre made raw or cooked brands for you to feed to your cat, but I don't know how to formulate DIY raw for cats for dogs. Come at me, come at me. I will give you all my information. Cats Absolutely not. That's not my wheelhouse yet. Here's my friend Jess. You know what I mean? Like there's everybody, not everybody can be an expert in everything. And I think being able to play on your strengths but then uplift others when they have those strengths that you don't is so important.

1:10:18 And I think that we do do a good job of that in this space and so. I do too. I think that's why it was so frustrating to feel like so many blanket statements were made. Yeah. Bear heard me get loud and I think he knows that my emotions are running high, so he came over to breathe heavily into the microphone. Well, and one thing that I want to say, and this is not something I don't think I've ever said to you before, but I somebody else said it to me and I had to sit with it for a while because I think we have some aligned beliefs in one of the certifications that we have. And, and somebody said this to me and I had to sit with it for a while to realize that with this particular certification, it's all recommendations. There are no treatment plans.

1:11:03 There's no like this is all recommendation based as, as a coach, everybody, whether you're a, a doctor or a veterinarian or a human health coach or a pet health coach, we all get our education and then we have to start out practicing practice. It's a practice because you have like a knowledge base and then you actually have to go out and use it and see how it works and see how things differ with different individuals. And like, you know, I'm supposed to do XYZ for this, but I have found that if I add this or take this away, it actually works better. Like the idea that it's called practice for a reason. I had to sit with that and be like, OK, like people need that breadth of space.

1:11:54 And that's not to say that it's going to work out for every one of them, but the reality is that like there is so much need that we need. We also need to give the people trying that are getting what the education that is out there, we need to give them the space to help because they may not be able to help with everything, but they're going to be able to help with some things. And is that, is that better than nothing? And I think it is, yeah. And, and just always making sure that you continue to learn and grow and educate, right? It that the buck doesn't stop when it doesn't you click the last like test that you took for your certification, right? Or when you get it in your e-mail or whatever, you have to keep calling from there.

1:12:38 And if you don't, then you have no business being around, in my opinion. Yeah. Yeah, no, I completely agree with that. I think we're kind of on on the same page there. But it was called out and it made me sad. And because not because they're 100% wrong, but that again, it's a blanket statement. It's a black or white and everything in this is Gray, I think. Yeah. And so this video, this 2 1/2 hour behemoth ends with them kind of like a call to action, right? To scientists, researchers, and like other people with quote, formal degrees. And they say that those people need to make more social content so that millions of people can get better information and essentially have their lives improved through science rather than only being able to get this information from people in the holistic space who they feel are spreading a lot of misinformation. And what I have to say about that is I spent 12 years. I know I look like a child, an adolescent in my senior year of high school, but I spent 12 years working in medicine, literally, sometimes savings people's lives. I'm not kidding.

1:13:52 Like I have. Yeah. You know, and sometimes all I do is sow A laceration. And sometimes I bring somebody back from having had a cardiac arrest. OK. Like I have done all ends of the spectrum. But despite the fact that you might feel comfortable coming into my ER and putting your life in my hands because I received that education, I had huge gaping holes in my education in the realm of nutrition, natural modalities, and holistic health. And those things should be a part of every well-rounded curriculum for somebody who is going into healthcare or veterinary care for animals. And it was not.

1:14:33 And so if you had come into my ER and wanted to talk to me about nutrition, I would have not had anything to say to you. So it is not fair to say scientists, researchers, and people with formal degrees are the only ones that you should be listening to because I would have Jack shift to say to you about nutrition 12 years ago or even five years ago. I had to go and find that information myself. I still put a fruit roll up in my lunch every day five years ago because I thought I ate chicken for dinner when I went home, so it was OK that I was eating, you know, colored plastic like, you know what I mean? Yeah, I do know. You can't just say you have a formal degree and so you are an authority on all things.

1:15:16 Yeah, it doesn't work like that. It's disrespectful for the people who have worked hard and went out and got that information and educated themselves just because it didn't come with a $20,000 two year college, you know, certificate or $100,000 six year college degree like mine. It's not. Fair. Especially today when we literally have every bit of information that we could ever want access to at our fingertips. Granted, not everybody is utilizing it. Most people are not utilizing it. But if you take the initiative to go out there and find that information and learn that information, like props to you because that's not easy.

1:16:00 In fact, I think it's harder than walking into a classroom and having it handed to you. Having it handed to you, but yeah, exactly because now with AI and you know, bless AI, whatever, it helps me like edit my my blog articles. But if I went into a ChatGPT that I haven't trained and I said is garlic safe for dogs, guess what answer I'm gonna get, right? No, yeah, yeah. So that doesn't mean you are an expert in all fields because you have a ChatGPT. It doesn't work like that. You still have to go out and actually find credible sources and Fact Check and get the information from a primary source and then be able to read it and understand it and apply it. So it takes work.

1:16:41 And to Foo all the people who do that work, shame on them. Yeah, I agree. And also I just want to say one thing about veterinary nutritionist, which by the way, I have so much, and I say this all the time, I have so much respect for veterinarians. Yeah, they have a knowledge base that I don't have. I am not here trying to tell anybody anything differently. I have a lot of respect for them. But my, my view based on what clients have brought to me of what you get from a veterinary nutritionist is just cut and paste AFCO like that's what you're getting. And I think people come to you and me because they have either, whether through education or something horrible happening to their pet, have realized that that's not what they want for their pet anymore.

1:17:39 There's a huge difference. I'm not saying veterinary nutritionists are bad or wrong. I'm saying that like there's room and there is a difference. And that difference is there for a very good reason. I agree. I agree. Well, I think the take away is there's room for growth, never stop learning and the world isn't black and white. It isn't, it isn't, and at the end of the day, learn what's click bait. Yeah. Like, there's so much click bait out there that I get that it's hard. I get that it's hard. This is a new responsibility that we have as humans in the world.

1:18:20 Yeah, to weed through it and find the right stuff. All right, I think that's it. I think that wraps us up. Yes. Yes, nice talking to you. You too. I know everybody keeps saying they want us to do more of these, so. I would love to, I'll try and be a little bit less Italian with my hands and my voice next time. Oh, I, oh, I talk with my hands. I talk with my hands. Yeah. Maybe like after the summer though, because you're moving with there's so much travel. There's AFCO, there's Super Zoo, which we're both going to be at. So we will probably do some, at least one live, maybe from AFCO. Yeah, yeah. And we'll, we'll, we'll figure all that out. All right, well. I'll talk to you soon. Alright guys, have a good day. Bye.

Kara Rose Hanrahan Profile Photo

Functional Medicine Nurse Practitioner, CPCN

My name is Kara, and I'm a Functional Medicine Nurse Practitioner, a Certified Canine Nutritionist, and a Holistic Health Practitioner for both People and Pets. Most importantly, I'm a passionate advocate about natural health and nutrition for the entire family.

My goal is to educate and empower individuals rather than prescribe to them. Because holistic health isn't a prescription; it's a partnership between knowledge, understanding and action. Your actions are what steer the ship, and I'm here to be the breeze in your sails guiding you toward health and longevity.

I spent a decade working as a critical care Nurse Practitioner as well as being a 'normal' pet parent who fed kibble and never questioned the pet professionals. And over that decade, I watched as conventional therapies repeatedly failed my patients and my pets who were struggling with chronic illnesses. It made me wonder what I was missing and how I could do better to improve not just our lifespan but our healthspan as well. This catalyst sparked the creation of Raw Remedies Health, where we explore natural health for every member of the family, including the furry ones!