211. AAFCO 2025 RECAP
In this episode, I give you the inside scoop from the AAFCO 2025 meeting. Short story: the rulebook is shifting, the FDA–AAFCO MOU is dissolving, and pet food labeling is still a maze built for manufacturers—not consumers. I break down what that shake-up actually means for your dog’s bowl—who writes the definitions, who enforces them, and where transparency falls apart.
I also call out the elephant in the room: there aren’t enough consumer voices at these tables. If we want cleaner sourcing, clearer labels, and real accountability, we have to show up. I’ll walk you through how to read past the marketing, what questions to ask brands, and where to plug into the process so we stop being spectators and start driving the standards.
🐶 🐱 Nutrition & Holistic Health Consults: https://jessicalfisher.com/product-category/holistic-pet-health-nutrition/
💜 Follow Jessica on Instagram https://www.instagram.com/thepetparentingreset/
📩 Get email notifications for new episodes:
https://jessicalfisher.kartra.com/page/tpprnotify
0:01 The American Association of Feed Control Officials, 2025 annual. Meeting was earlier. In August and I attended again this year and so today's episode we're kind of running down some of my takeaways from this year's meeting. If you are new here, thank you so much for being here. My name is Jessica. I am a certified canine nutritionist and holistic pet health coach and this is the Pet Parenting Reset where I bring you all kinds of incredible information for making better choices for your pets, for their health and for their happiness or hopefully an extended life, but certainly a healthier life. With that, let's jump into AFCO.
0:41 So AFCO is not a regulatory body. We talk about this all the time on the podcast they provide. They have been contracted for, I don't know, over 100 years, something like that to by the FDA, excuse me, by the FDA too, provide guidelines for not just pet food, but feed, which is why it's the association of feed control officials. So all you know, livestock feed, all the things, they cover it all. And. So it's a crazy time. It's a crazy, crazy time. We've talked a little bit about the Per Act in the past. If you've missed those episodes, you can certainly go back to them. And the Per Act is still in Congress. But it is basics.
1:23 It's dissolving the memorandum of understanding, our MOU between FDACVM, which is the Center for Veterinary Medicine at the FDA, Food and Drug Administration with AFCO that has been in place for a very, very long time. Some of the things that were talked about this year were kind of follow up from last year because last year was like, Oh my gosh, what is happening? Like people in the room were silent because nobody knew what was going on, what is happening. And I think we're still kind of in that place. But AFCO is definitely grasping to remain relevant and the FDA is saying that they are still going to work with AFCO, just not in the same ways. Anyway, we're going to get into all of that really quickly. I want to present to you a really incredible product that I have been using for Kim, and I want to say thank you because without sponsors, this podcast may not continue. OK, so welcome back.
5:23 And so the AFCO 2025 Annual Meeting opened up with a keynote speaker, Timothy Shell, who is the acting FDACVM director. Some of the things he said. So first of all, he said a lot without saying anything, which is always interesting because politicians kind of have a knack for that. And he definitely, there was a lot of political speech speak at this AFCO meeting all around because so FDACVM actually brought in, I think it was over 20 people to the meeting. It was a very well attended meeting. It was in Omaha this year, which actually was a really cute little city. Cara and I, Cara from Rawpaw Adventures and I did a live. We were supposed to do 2, but we ran out of time on the second day.
6:07 We did a live on the first day to kind of recap what we heard that day. So that was super fun. But some of the things he did say is that he was speaking specifically about color additives. And what he said is that what happens in the human space will be mirrored in the animal space. So for example, the red dye, the the one red dye that has been banned and they've given, I don't know how many years to get that out of human food that is going to be mirrored in the pet space. I don't know any more than that. But it sounds like their intention. Is that any anything happening in the human food space as far as like banning additives, banning colors, dyes, banning things that are in food that that is going to translate into pet food, which is a really good thing in my opinion. Hopefully they follow through with that. That's obviously something he just said out loud and was I don't know if it's on paper anywhere. And then of course he he just made note, made mention that the grass system that generally recognizes safe system is obviously something that is a big deal right now. That is being talked about by the Health and Human Services Secretary, Secretary Robert F Kennedy Junior, and talking about looking at this and really seeing if it is a good system or not.
7:25 Timothy Shell seemed to feel that whatever happens in the human space will also take place in the pet food space, in the feed control space. And then they talked about animal food ingredient consultation, replacing the AFCO MOU. So this is something that the FDA will take over, has taken over from AFCO, which is a big part of what AFCO did for the FDA. So again, AFCO representatives kind of grasping at straws and we'll talk about a little bit later on as well. One of the things that I found most interesting is that especially in his in Timothy Shell's speech, but it was kind of throughout and some of the other speakers saying this as well, they all said that we were all there for one common goal and that goal being to provide the safest food possible.
8:17 I disagree. I am not there for that reason. I am there because I want the healthiest food possible. And so I think that they're missing the mark a little bit, but that is what they think they're there for. That is their goal. Their goal is to take waste, industrial waste, and make it as safe as possible in their eyes, for animals to eat. So that is very disconcerting for me. But that's what happened with that. There were, gosh, there was so much being talked about. Let's see here, I'm going through my notes in this book. So one of the things that I found interesting, they ratified a new definition of fish.
9:01 Fish is undecomposed whole fish or flesh derived from the skeletal muscle, with or without. Accompanying bone exclusive and of any. Added heads, fends, tails, skin, bones, and viscera, except in such amounts as might occur unavoidably and processing. It shall be suitable for use in animal food. It is intended for use in animal food as a source of protein, consistent with good feeding practices. If it bears a name descriptive of its kind, it must correspond there too. So again, one of the things that I don't like, because I work with someone, I wouldn't want to feed this to my family. That also means my pets. But I work with so many animals that have sensitivities and to allow people to allow manufacturers to just put fish on a label is not at all transparent.
9:50 Now it does say if it bears a name descriptive of its kind, it must correspond there too. Meaning that if a particular fish is defined, then it has to say that particular fish. I feel like all fish should should be defined. Like if we don't know what it is, then why are we feeding it? So just having something that says fish is very concerning for me, but it is obviously allowed because there is a definition for it and you may have seen it if you looked at ingredient labels. Something else that I find very interesting that AFCO ratified the official method for fluorine, FLUORINE in animal feed.
10:34 This is an ion selective electrode method that was developed to analyze for fluoride in animal feed. But the results of the method are to be expressed as or reported as fluorine. This means that the method actually detects fluoride and not fluorine. Therefore guarantees or specifications for fluorine are actually for fluoride. Isn't that confusing and they're just saying OK, well it is what it is so we'll define it as such instead of saying no, fix it, No, fix it. That's what I'm saying, no fix it. Also anything black soldier fly larvae and black soldier fly larvae oil. These are probably going to be very common. I don't know in pet food, but it seems like it they might eventually because they've been ratified in the definition for AS part of what can be like an ingredient. It's an ingredient definition.
11:28 But what's interesting to me, and if you don't know this, if you are not following along, which nobody is, consumers are the biggest percentage of people affected that need representation in feed and food for for pets. And yet they have absolutely no representation and it is terrifying. So you might look at there might be like, I don't know, maybe even an organic certification, I don't know. This is speculation on my part for a food that has black soldier fly larvae or black soldier fly larvae oil. And then you don't know because the truth is the definition says that those larvae which are approved to be used in adult dog and adult cat foods, those larvae are exclusively fed feed grade materials.
12:19 So even though you might look at this and say, OK, well it's a, it's a healthy protein source, but those larvae are only fed feed grade materials. Just like when we talk about what a cow eats or what a pig eats and that affecting its nutrients and that affecting the energetics and that affecting you or your pets consuming that food, same goes with this. And so it's not going to be expressly written. That's just part of the definition. And by the way. Definitions. Of ingredients in pet food is available for purchase. They are not free. You can purchase them as a consumer. You have to purchase them as a manufacturer. And I believe it's 250. Dollars a year. Something like that.
13:01 If you want to know what that is. So I'm I'm not going to go through everything that was talked about obviously at the AFCO meeting. Just pulling up some of the big ones. One of the things that I did circle is that there was a new ingredient beta mayonnaise. I have no idea how to say that word. It is a strain of bacteria and the intended use says utility information not evaluated for grass that generally recognizes safe system. And then the FDA's letter says FDA has no questions. So I'm sure this is very common. And maybe to somebody else is like, OK, whatever. But to me it's saying that like not even evaluated in the generally recognized safe system. And the FDA is like, OK, first of all, we don't like the grass system to begin with.
13:56 But then if we're not even using it, what are we using again? Rent Red dye #3 is going it has a sunset date of January 1st, 2027. So it is going to be a withdrawn ingredient. And then here we go. OK, so according to the per act, the FDACVM is going to be the final arbitrator regulating food safety labels, labeling and advertising. The states will continue testing, working with the FDA, inspections and education and they are touting this as regulatory harmony. Is is specifically what a quote I heard and the FDA and the FTC already are. They're already responsible for the authority of I can't read my own handwriting of claims.
14:44 They codify the language for the OP, which is the like regulation book that AFCO created. So they already codified that language. So they're, they're just going to continue using it basically they're not going to create their own. They're going to say, OK, we've been using this forever. We're just going to go ahead and continue using it as our own. And the states still choose to work with the FDA. And then federally they're going to codify pet food labeling. So that's kind of like the highlight of the per act is that there's going to be like one federal food labeling regulation, whereas right now every individual states of 50 states have their own, which is very difficult for manufacturers, especially small manufacturers. So yeah, the the and then they talk, they went back to 19 O 9. So it has been more than 100 years. Nineteen O 9 is when AFCO originally started basically contracting for the FDA and the whole point. Of AFCO.
15:48 Was to get all of the states on one page and it has been over 100 years and they haven't been able to do that. So it does kind of make sense that the federal government wants to take it back over. So let's get to the second day at AFCO. Yeah. So they were supposed to give updates on HPP because there's no definition for HPP. They were supposed to give a definition for jerky and still has not been defined. And they're supposed to be a definition for gently cooked, which is also not defined. None of that has happened. They requested work groups. They don't have official work groups. What's interesting with all of this is that we use HPP in human food manufacturing. So I feel like there should be some definition somewhere of it.
16:30 I don't know. And then jerky, like how long has jerky been sold? And there's no definition for it. That's kind of crazy as well. And then gently cooked. So I think along the same lines as as and then the common food index, we added dates, pumpkin seeds, honeydew, cantaloupe and spinach. What was really funny was somebody was like, I'm shocked we added honeydew in cantaloupe because who knows what that actually is. And I was like, what like don't we know about? Actually, I don't know, maybe I'm wrong on that. You can let me know. But also they brought up, which is so silly. They brought up food versus feed again. Now, the reason I say this is so silly is because it's like, yes, as a consumer, I absolutely want to look at this again.
17:16 But as like AFCO, this is done, this is handled. This is, they've already decided that these two words are to be used interchangeably. So anywhere you see the word food, they mean feed and vice versa is what they're saying. These two words are interchangeable. As far as AFCO is concerned, that's handled. That's done. I don't like it, but it's handled and it's done. So that's why I say it's silly. But somebody actually got on the mic and said, who even cares about this anymore? And I was like, wow, like, tell me, tell me there are no consumers on these panels without telling me there are no consumers on these panels, right? Because even though consumers are the largest group affected by pet food and feed regulation, they have no, no say. They have no presence in regulation whatsoever. And it drives me up the wall.
18:19 And manufacturers, even even healthy pet food manufacturers don't care either. They're like, leave it the way it is because they can use feed grade ingredients and still call it food. And some of our some of the foods that we feed, some of the foods that I even recommend are technically they have feed grade ingredients on them because this is just the way of the world for pet food. But some of the. Reasons that were given for not going back to redefine this is that one, it's too much work. 2 Does anybody care? That was actually asked and then it was admitted by almost everybody that yes, it is very confusing, but Nope, they are not fixing it.
19:03 So pet food manufacturers may be fine with that, industry may be fine with that. Feed control may be fine with that. As a consumer, I'm not fine with that. I want to know the difference. I want, I want a pet food package or a pet feed package to say if it is food grade or if it is feed grade. That's what I want. So on the second day, to kind of close out the day, we had a presentation from Doctor Kathy Gross. She is a PhD diplomat from the American College of Animal Nutrition. She recently retired after a 32 year career at Hills Pet Nutrition and she gave a presentation on pet obesity.
19:46 And here are some of my takeaways from her talk. She still believes that reducing reducing calories is the way to combat this, that reducing calories will keep pets a healthy weight. I think this is a very short sighted argument. Obesity is an inflammatory disease and she did not talk about that and there was a lot of irony going on. She also could not seem even though she had trends and graphs and. Showing like. Pet obesity and time overtime blah blah blah. Somehow she could not see the correlation between the overweight epidemic starting and the timing of ultra processed foods. She also barely mentioned anything about a species or no.
20:28 She didn't say anything about a biologically or a species appropriate diet. There was one mention it was like an afterthought. She gave like, all of these things, like, I don't know, 15 things that needed to be done to combat pet obesity. And the last thing she said with like a second, like a blip on the screen was like, maybe we should consider fresh foods. I don't know. We need to look into that more. It wasn't even a definitive. It was just like, I don't know, maybe. And then went on with her talk. It was very, very short sighted. And the idea that just a reduction in calories is going to do it is asinine to me as a health coach or just, I don't know, as a human walking this planet, understanding how inflammation plays a key role in everything and how kibble is the most inflammatory food that we could be feeding our pets believe, yeah, pretty much the most inflammatory food that we could possibly be feeding our pets.
21:22 But so anyway, AFCO was very frustrating this year. It's a lot of just sitting there being bored, and every once in a while you're like, Oh my God, did I just hear what I heard? That's the AFCO meeting. But the reality is we need more consumers there. We need a bigger presence. We need to let people know that we actually care in a meaningful way. You know, one thing that did happen this year that I'm very grateful for. So 2024 I had to pay $500 to attend. They reduce the fee for consumers to $250 this year.
22:02 And so I feel like, and that was that took a lot of talking. Like Susan had to really push, Kathy Doctor, Kathy Alanovi had to really push. And I think they listened and they're like, OK, well, let's see, let's give it a go. And I know you know, Cara with Rawala Adventure, she also came this year. So she had the benefit of paying half what I paid last year to go. And then of course, you have travel, you know, airfare and hotel and all of that, that has to be paid as well. So it's not cheap. And so I get why people don't go, but and it's boring and it's frustrating. But when we don't attend, the only like they get to do what they want and they get to look and say, well, you're not attending so you obviously don't care.
22:49 And that's one of the biggest like takeaways for me is like, no, it's not fun. And no, I am not happy about the things I'm hearing, but I have every intention to continue showing up because I do care. And I, I don't know, that's just my way, my message, especially to healthy pet food manufacturers, please show up as well. Some of them do, but not all of them. And you know, please show up because what you do matters. Consumers, please show up. We are the biggest percentage that is affected by this and we're not showing up.
23:31 And no, they don't make it easy. They do not make it easy. They don't want us there. That's exactly why we have to be there. So I hope I didn't ramble too much, but that's kind of the highlights from the AFCO 2025 Annual Annual meeting. Let me know if you have any questions about that and let me know if any of this frustrates you as much as it frustrates me. I don't know. I know that like these AFCO updates, this is just a second one, but they're, they tend to be like the ones that people don't get into as far as episodes go as much as other episodes. But I just, I mean, it's important guys. Like this is this is the regulation and it's still our only connection to FDACVM at the moment. I don't know how that's going to look moving forward. I don't think anybody does.
24:17 But that's another reason why I'm attending is to figure out what this is going to look like moving forward because we need to know consumers or pets are being affected by everything they do. And so we need to know what they're doing. So with that, I'm going to go ahead and end today's episode. I want to say thank you again to Legacy Biome for being sponsor for this week's podcast. And if you have any questions about APCO, if you have any questions about Legacy Biome, reach out to me. Instagram is the best way to do that. Of course, I'm at the pet parenting reset guys. I just can't wait for next week. We have another incredible guest coming next week and I have so many more ahead for the rest of the year for you guys. With that, please give your pet some extra love from me today. And here is a message from Legacy Biome one more time. All right, pet parents, you already know that I talk. All the time about.
25:08 Needing to stop as much. As we possibly can feeding our fur babies garbage, for lack of a better word. That's what we talked about here a lot. And again, doing the best we can. That is the message. Above any and everything else, the more we learn, the more we know we need to make some changes and this episode is powered by Legacy Biome. This is no BS and This is why I. Think you need legacy Biome? So legacy Biome offers premium. When I say premium, I mean premium FMT, fecal microbiota transplant capsules. These are products. For your dog. Designed to restore and support a healthy gut microbiome.
25:50 Yes, you heard me top tier microbiome therapy straight from nature's playbook. Gut health isn't optional. We talk about this all the time. It's not optional. It drives digestion, immune strength, allergy resistance, mood, and even. Chronic disease risk. So if your pet. 'S gut is out of whack. Their whole system. Is out of whack. If you've learned nothing from me thus far, I think you should know that. So legacy Biome tells us. That their donor animals live on a raw organic diet and pristine chemical free environments generations. Bred to preserve a rugged. And unaltered microbiome. No antibiotics, no pesticides, no synthetic crap ever.
26:30 And they screen those. Donors with the strictest protocols. In the industry. Kim's over here next to me, if you can hear. Her So if you have a pet that is. Wrestling with chronic diarrhea, itchy skin, hair loss, allergies, rebounding from antibiotics? That's a thing too. Legacy Biome is your weapon. Heck, you can just use it proactively to build a bulletproof gut and immune health. So don't worry, that's handle. This FMT is administered rectally, often through veterinarians offices, but we don't always have access to that. So what's the next best thing? FMT capsules that are enteric coded that you can get delivered.
27:13 Straight to your home from the most.
Apple Podcasts
Spotify
Castro
RSS Feed
Goodpods
YouTube
iHeartRadio